All-American Murder is a 1991 horror film filled with mystery and romance. The story unfolds when the new kid in college almost instantaneously falls in love with a girl named Tally. Tally is recognized as the most beautiful and popular girl on campus, and once she agrees to go on a date with Artie, the plot takes an unsuspecting twist. The night of the date, Tally is brutally murdered and Artie is arrested and becomes the prime suspect. Will Artie be able to clear his name of the murder, or will all signs point back to him?