Eating Out 2: Sloppy Seconds is both a gay and romantic comedy movie. Kyle breaks up with Marc, his love interest from the first movie. He accused him of frequently flirting with the hottest men. Tiffani, Gwen, and Kyle, very close friends from the first movie, become attracted to Troy, a fashioned cowboy from Troy, Illinois. Troy liked posing nude for their art classes.
Troy easily confides in them after befriending both. He tells them that he had constantly slept with both men and women alike. However, he is extremely reluctant to practice or embrace any gay feelings.
After Marc had dumped him, Kyle will later unite with Tiffani and Gwen to befriend a sexually muddled art model Troy by constantly pretending to be very straight; however, Marc also wants Troy.