A.K.A. Savage Islands, Nate and Hayes has become a swashbuckling pirate cult favorite. Set in the Caribbean in the golden age of piracy, Nate Williamsen (Michael O'Keefe) has been sent to an island as a missionary, accompanied by Sophie (Jenny Seagrove), his fiancée. They are to be missionaries and are ferried to their new home by a charming yet gruff Captain Hayes (Tommy Lee Jones, loosely based on a real captain who sailed the South Pacific during the mid 1800s). It is not long before slave traders raid the island and Sophie is kidnapped. Can Nate and Hayes rescue her?