A newborn baby is found dead in a pond on an Amish farm and all of the evidence of the murder points to one person. Katie Fitch was proven to have been pregnant, but she swears she is still a virgin. Police officials do not believe her and they take her into custody. A big time female lawyer is convinced to take the case for a friend of hers, but she does not know what she is in for. The deeper she digs to find the truth, the more confusing the case gets. She is no longer sure she believes that her client is innocent.