Boyd and his party quickly discover that Colqhoun has led them into a trap. One by one, Colqhoun kills the party members. Boyd escapes but is badly injured. While hiding, he survives off the flesh of one of the murdered soldiers. Once he makes it back to the fort, he tells his unbelievable story to the remaining soldiers who haven't seen Colqhoun. Moments later, Colqhoun shows back up and presents himself as Colonel Ives. Although Boyd warns the soldiers of what happened, the soldiers refuse to believe him.
Colqhoun kills the remaining soldiers and makes a stew with their flesh. With Boyd chained up, Colqhoun admits he attempted the Wendigo myth and was transformed into a cannibal. He also plans to use the fort to trap and kill more victims. Boyd gets loose from the chains and battles Colqhoun. They are both snapped together in a large bear trap. Colqhoun dies first, and Boyd, who could save himself refuses to eat his flesh to live. He too succumbs to his wounds. When General Slauson arrives, he helps himself to a bowl of stew.