Ep 13. The Nightman Cometh

Charlie is an artist, a janitor, and a writer. He has created a musical to express his love for the Waitress, a woman he has been obsessed with for years. His friends Dennis, Mac, Dee, and Frank reluctantly agree to help him put on the show at a local bar.

The musical, titled "The Nightman Cometh," is a bizarre, surreal production that follows the story of a boy named Charlie, who becomes the Nightman to fight off the evil Dayman and win the love of the Princess (played by the Waitress). The songs are catchy but disturbing, and the costumes are homemade and shoddy.

As the gang rehearses and performs the musical, tensions rise and secrets are revealed. Dennis becomes jealous of Charlie's infatuation with the Waitress and starts to pursue her himself. Frank takes on the role of the Troll, a character who aims to sabotage the Nightman's quest. Dee struggles with her role as the Princess and her hidden desire to be a star. Mac takes on the role of the Dayman, but his efforts are hampered by his lack of musical ability.

Despite the chaos and dysfunction, the gang manages to put on a memorable show, culminating in a dramatic finale that includes a surprise twist. Along the way, they explore themes of love, friendship, and the pursuit of dreams.

"The Nightman Cometh" is a standout episode of It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia, showcasing the show's signature blend of irreverent humor and dark subject matter. The musical sequences are hilarious and uncomfortable, and the performances by the main cast are some of their best. The episode also features guest appearances by some of the show's recurring characters, including Rickety Cricket and the McPoyles.

Overall, "The Nightman Cometh" is a must-watch for fans of the show and anyone who enjoys offbeat comedy. It's a testament to the creativity and fearlessness of the It's Always Sunny team and a reminder of why the show has remained a cult favorite for over a decade.