Ep 5. Joel Gideon

Joel Gideon is the fifth episode of the second season of the controversial medical drama Nip/Tuck. This episode follows the lives of two best friends, Joel and Gideon, who found each other in college and have been inseparable ever since. However, things take a dark turn when Joel, who is a successful television producer, is diagnosed with a rare cancer. Gideon, who is a doctor, offers to take his friend's case and treat him with a new and experimental treatment.

The episode starts with a flashback of Joel and Gideon in college, where they first met. It's clear from the beginning that their bond is strong, and the scene hints at how much they have gone through together. However, their friendship is threatened when Joel receives his diagnosis and Gideon offers to treat him. The tension between them is palpable as they navigate their roles as friend and doctor.

As Joel begins his treatment, he starts to struggle with the side effects of the medication. He feels nauseous and weak, and his appearance begins to change. This puts a strain on his relationship with his girlfriend, who can't handle the changes and begins to distance herself. Meanwhile, Gideon's professional reputation is at risk as he tries to push the boundaries of medical science to save his friend.

The episode explores the theme of identity and how illness can change a person's sense of self. Joel, who used to be a confident and successful man, now feels like he's losing control of his life. He becomes consumed by his illness and starts to see himself as a "cancer patient" first and foremost, losing sight of who he was before. The scene where he looks at himself in the mirror and sees only an illness staring back at him is especially haunting.

At the same time, Gideon grapples with his own identity as a doctor and a friend. He struggles to balance his desire to save Joel with his ethical responsibilities as a medical professional. The episode raises questions about the limits of medical science and the ethical implications of pushing those limits.

One of the strengths of the episode is the nuanced portrayal of the characters and their relationships. The writing is subtle and doesn't resort to melodrama or cheap emotional manipulation. The actors give strong performances, especially Julian McMahon as Gideon, who gives a nuanced and complex portrayal of a conflicted doctor.

In addition to the main storyline, there are also some subplots that add depth and texture to the episode. One of the more lighthearted subplots involves the ongoing rivalry between Sean and Christian, the two plastic surgeons who are the main characters of the show. Their bickering and one-upmanship provide a much-needed comedic relief from the darker themes of the episode.

Overall, Joel Gideon is a powerful and thought-provoking episode that deftly explores complex themes of identity, friendship, and medical ethics. It's a testament to the show's ability to tackle controversial topics with nuance and sensitivity. Fans of Nip/Tuck will find much to appreciate here, and newcomers may find themselves drawn into the show's world of high-stakes medicine and complex interpersonal relationships.