But Can They Sing?

Watch But Can They Sing?

  • 2005
  • 1 Season
  • 5.5  (41)

But Can They Sing? was a reality television show that aired on VH1 in 2005. The show was created by one of the producers of Dancing with the Stars, and was hosted by former NFL player Ahmad Rashad. The premise of the show was simple: to find out if celebrities known for their acting, modeling or other careers could also sing.

Throughout the eight-episode season, viewers watched as the eight contestants - Joe Pantoliano, Michael Copon, Kim Alexis, Myrka Dellanos, Carmine Gotti Agnello, Ahmet Zappa, Larry Holmes, and Antonio Sabato Jr. - were put through various singing challenges to determine their vocal abilities. Each episode featured a different theme, including country, rock, and disco, and the contestants were judged on their performances by a panel of music industry experts.

One of the highlights of the show was the surprising talent displayed by some of the contestants. While some, such as Kim Alexis and Larry Holmes, struggled to hit the right notes and keep up with the tempo, others, including Joe Pantoliano and Michael Copon, had surprisingly impressive singing voices. Ahmet Zappa, the son of legendary musician Frank Zappa, also showcased his musical talents, proving that the apple didn't fall far from the tree.

Another aspect of the show that kept audiences engaged was the drama and tension that arose between the contestants. With such a diverse group of individuals from different backgrounds and careers, clashes were bound to happen. In one episode, for example, tensions ran high when Myrka Dellanos called out Antonio Sabato Jr. for being rude to the other contestants. And in another episode, Carmine Gotti Agnello's performance was criticized for being too "karaoke-like," causing him to lash out at the judges.

Throughout the show, viewers were also treated to behind-the-scenes footage of the contestants rehearsing, interacting with each other, and dealing with the pressures of being in the spotlight. These glimpses into the contestants' personal lives added depth and dimension to the show, and allowed viewers to connect with the contestants on a more personal level.

Despite the drama, tension, and occasional mishaps on stage, But Can They Sing? remained an entertaining and engaging reality show throughout its run. It was a unique opportunity to see celebrities step outside of their comfort zones and try something new, and viewers were able to follow along on their journeys as they discovered hidden talents and tackled new challenges. Whether they were professional actors, models, or athletes, these contestants proved that they could do more than just their day jobs. They could also sing.

Filter by Source
No sources available
Seasons
Season 1, Episode 6
6. Season 1, Episode 6
December 4, 2005
Playtime is over. Everyone's had their shot, singing duets, working the crowd and pulling out all the stops. Only three contestants remain. But America can only choose one winner.
Season 1, Episode 5
5. Season 1, Episode 5
November 27, 2005
Summary is not available.
Season 1, Episode 4
4. Season 1, Episode 4
November 20, 2005
They can act, model and even box, but can they sing? That's the question VH1 will ask and answer this fall with the new series But Can They Sing when nine celebrities vie for the chance to prove to America whether they should stick to their day job or tough it out over six weeks to become a pop star. Actors Morgan Fairchild, Joe Pantaliano, Bai Ling, Antonio Sabato, Jr, Michael Copon, model Kim Alexis, Carmine Gotti, heavyweight champion Larry Holmes and Latin entertainer/journalist Myrka Dellanos have been chosen to compete against one another in this new original series. Each week, these hopefuls will undergo grueling and intensive training with two prominent vocal coaches and one movement/dance instructor to prepare for their performance in front of a live studio audience at the end of the week. VH1 will then turn the decision over to America, who will have the chance to decide who stays and who goes home.
Season 1, Episode 3
3. Season 1, Episode 3
November 13, 2005
They can act, model and even box, but can they sing? That's the question VH1 will ask and answer this fall with the new series But Can They Sing when nine celebrities vie for the chance to prove to America whether they should stick to their day job or tough it out over six weeks to become a pop star. Actors Morgan Fairchild, Joe Pantaliano, Bai Ling, Antonio Sabato, Jr, Michael Copon, model Kim Alexis, Carmine Gotti, heavyweight champion Larry Holmes and Latin entertainer/journalist Myrka Dellanos have been chosen to compete against one another in this new original series. Each week, these hopefuls will undergo grueling and intensive training with two prominent vocal coaches and one movement/dance instructor to prepare for their performance in front of a live studio audience at the end of the week. VH1 will then turn the decision over to America, who will have the chance to decide who stays and who goes home.
Season 1, Episode 2
2. Season 1, Episode 2
November 6, 2005
Playtime is over. Everybody's had their shot. And everyone's a winner...except for the celebrities that must depart the show as the competition really gets going in episode two of "But Can They Sing?" Our celebrities continue their demanding schedule of vocal and performance training--all in the hope of two very noble causes: not embarrassing themselves in front of millions and winning a grand prize for charity. Everyone's practicing their scales, picking their outfits, and drinking lots of hot tea and honey. Will it make a difference? The votes from the first week have been tabulated--and the results are in-whose voice will be silenced and whose pipes will be polished for next week's show?
Season 1, Episode 1
1. Season 1, Episode 1
October 30, 2005
Welcome to the newest, brightest star in the "celebreality" universe! VH1 brings together celebrity and singing in a hip and hilarious mash-up of competitive entertainment. Watch as nine celebrities from all over the showbusiness map battle it out in a musical contest that showcases their singing talent-or lack of-to the world. And when the dust settles at the end of each episode, America will vote for its favorite celebrity performers and ultimately decide who wins a big money prize for charity. But it won't be easy. Our celebrities will be put through an intensive regimen of vocal and performance classes by some of the top coaches in the music industry. Whose voice will crack? Who might forget a line? And who will shockingly pull it all off? Find out when we finally answer one of the great questions of our time: But Can They Sing?"
Description
  • Premiere Date
    October 30, 2005
  • IMDB Rating
    5.5  (41)
Watch Apple TV+ Originals
Do you have Apple TV?
Ad Info
No thanks, I'm not interested in Apple TV