Cold Case Files Classic Season 2 Episode 9 The Unluckiest Man/The Deadly Triangle

In Cold Case Files Classic season 2 episode 9, viewers are taken on a journey into two separate cases that both involve unlucky circumstances and deadly consequences.

The first case, "The Unluckiest Man," examines the murder of a young man named Timmy Wiltsey in New Jersey in 1991. Timmy vanished from a local fair, and his mother reported him missing that same night. Despite an extensive search, Timmy's body was not found until a year later when a serial killer confessed to the crime. However, the killer's confession was later recanted, and doubts grew surrounding his guilt. This case takes a closer look at the investigation into Timmy's murder, the initial search efforts, and the subsequent trials. Viewers will also hear from Timmy's mother, who never gave up hope of finding her son's killer and has dedicated her life to advocating for child safety.

The second case, "The Deadly Triangle," follows the investigation into the disappearance of a young woman named Tracy Jo Shine in Texas in 1987. Tracy was last seen leaving her job at a fast-food restaurant and getting into a vehicle with two men that she knew. The two men, who were identified by witnesses and later arrested, told the police that they dropped Tracy off at a local convenience store and did not know what happened to her after that. Despite their claims, investigators were able to piece together the events leading up to Tracy's disappearance and eventually discovered her remains in a remote area. This case focuses on the investigation into Tracy's murder, including interviews with witnesses and the two men who were ultimately charged with the crime.

As with all episodes of Cold Case Files Classic, viewers can expect a thorough and in-depth exploration of each case. Interviews with investigators, family members, and other key players provide insight into the investigation process and the impact that these crimes had on the local communities. The show balances the grisly details of each case with a focus on the humanity of those involved, reminding viewers that there are real people impacted by these horrific crimes.