Cold Case Files Classic Season 3 Episode 16 The Lady Killer/A Map To Murder

In this episode of Cold Case Files Classic, we follow the investigation into the disturbing case of a serial killer known as "The Lady Killer." The case begins in 1987 when police find the body of a 28-year-old woman named Terry Reynolds in a dumpster. Reynolds had been strangled and her body was left naked and mutilated.

Through the course of their investigation, police discovered two other victims, both of whom had also been strangled and mutilated in a similar way. The killer had been targeting young, vulnerable women who were addicted to drugs and involved in prostitution. However, despite their best efforts, police were unable to identify a suspect, and the case went cold.

Years later, in 1999, a man named Carlton Gary was arrested and convicted for a string of murders in Georgia. As detectives looked more closely at his past, they discovered a potential link to the Lady Killer case. Gary had lived in the same area as the murders and had a history of attacking women. Furthermore, a map showing the location of the Lady Killer's victims was found in Gary's home.

The episode delves into the investigation that followed, as detectives tried to determine if Gary was, in fact, the Lady Killer. They spoke to witnesses who had seen Gary in the area around the time of the murders and discovered that he had a distinct pattern of leaving town after each murder. They also spoke to some of Gary's former cellmates, who claimed that he had confessed to the Lady Killer murders.

Despite the mounting evidence, Gary continued to maintain his innocence, and his defense team argued that the map found in his home was not conclusive evidence of guilt. In the end, a jury found him guilty of all the charges against him, including the Lady Killer murders, and he was sentenced to death.

Overall, this episode of Cold Case Files Classic is a chilling look at the investigation into one of the most disturbing and elusive serial killers in recent history. It is a reminder of the dedication and persistence of law enforcement officials who work tirelessly to bring justice to the families of victims, even when the trail seems to have gone cold.