Watch What Shall We Tell Caroline

What Shall We Tell Caroline is a heartwarming British film made in 1958, directed by Anthony Pelissier with Michael Hordern and Leueen Emily MacGrath in lead roles. It is based on the novel of the same name by Monica Dickens. The film beautifully captures the essence of human relationships and family bonds while exploring themes of love, loss, trust, and second chances.

The story revolves around Caroline, a ten-year-old girl who lives with her grandparents Sir William and Lady Margaret Faraday in a big house in the countryside. Caroline's mother is no longer alive, and her father is away in Africa, working as a doctor. Caroline is a quiet, timid, and inquisitive child who is always fascinated by the stories of her family's past and the mysteries surrounding them. She is curious to know why her mother never came to live with them and what happened to her.

The narrative takes a turn when Caroline's father unexpectedly returns home and decides that it is time for Caroline to come and live with him in Africa. However, Caroline is not ready to leave her grandparents or the familiarity of her home. She feels that she belongs in England, and she wants to uncover the truth about her mother's past. Thus, Caroline sets on a mission to unravel the secrets of her family's past and discover the truth about her mother.

Along the way, Caroline meets her eccentric great-aunt, Aunt Lucasta, who becomes her guide and confidant, helping her navigate through the complexities of her family's history. Aunt Lucasta is a free-spirited and witty character who brings a much-needed dose of humor and warmth to Caroline's life. Together, they discover a old diary hidden in the attic, which provides vital clues about Caroline's mother's past and sheds light on the untold stories of the Faraday family.

The film's strength lies in its portrayal of the relationships between the characters. Caroline's bond with her grandparents is heart-warming and genuine, and their love for her is palpable, despite their different opinions about her future. The film also explores the themes of second chances and forgiveness, as Caroline's father tries to make amends for his past mistakes and reconnect with his daughter.

The film is shot in a simplistic manner, yet it manages to capture the beauty of the English countryside and the grandeur of the Faraday estate. The film's score by Benjamin Frankel adds a touch of nostalgia and melancholy to the story, perfectly complementing the mood of the film.

Overall, the film is a tender and poignant portrayal of a young girl's quest for answers about her past and her journey towards self-discovery. It is a timeless classic that reminds us of the importance of family bonds, forgiveness, and second chances in life. What Shall We Tell Caroline is a must-watch for those who appreciate intimate family dramas and heart-warming coming-of-age stories that stand the test of time.