Cold Case Files Classic Season 2 Episode 12 The Good Samaritan/Cat And Mouse

In the twelfth episode of season two of Cold Case Files Classic, viewers are taken on a journey to unravel two separate cases that were investigated by the police department, each requiring a different set of skills to decipher the evidence. The episode, titled "The Good Samaritan/Cat And Mouse," showcases the expertise of the detectives of the Cold Case Squad as they navigate through complex cases that have remained unsolved for years.

The first case, "The Good Samaritan," is about an elderly woman who was brutally murdered in her home in the small town of Fairfield, Ohio, on Easter Sunday in 1994. The woman, who was known for her kindness and generosity, was found with her throat slit and her home ransacked. The police arrived at the scene soon after receiving a call from her son, who had found her body when he came to visit her. Despite numerous leads, the detectives were unable to identify any suspects or gather any concrete evidence. The case went cold, and the community lived in fear of a ruthless killer being on the loose.

Fast forward to 2005, and a new set of detectives takes up the case. Shedding new light on the case with the help of modern technology, the detectives try to solve the murder by re-analyzing the DNA evidence collected from the crime scene. They discover a crucial lead, and their investigation leads them to a suspect who had never come up in previous inquiries. The outcome of the investigation is both surprising and shocking.

The second case, "Cat and Mouse," is a twisted tale of deception and murder. In 1984, 65-year-old Donald Messer was found shot to death in his home in Kenosha, Wisconsin. The police found no signs of forced entry, and the evidence suggests that the killer was familiar with the house and the victim. During the investigation, the detectives came across an unusual suspect - a local taxi driver, who was known to have had a contentious relationship with the victim. The driver claimed to have been at home sleeping at the time of the murder and denied any involvement in the killing.

Despite their suspicions, the detectives were unable to gather enough evidence to convict the taxi driver. The case went cold, and the killer remained at large.

In 2000, the Kenosha Police Department formed a Cold Case Unit, and the murder of Donald Messer was one of the first cases assigned to them. The detectives analyzed the physical evidence collected from the scene, including bloodstains and shell casings, and used modern forensic techniques to re-examine the evidence. As they dug deeper, they uncovered a startling web of lies and deceit, leading to a suspect who had successfully evaded capture for over a decade.

"The Good Samaritan/Cat and Mouse" showcases the perseverance and dedication of law enforcement officers, who tirelessly work to bring justice to the families of victims of violent crimes. It also demonstrates the importance of modern technology and forensic science in solving complex cases that were once considered unsolvable. The episode is a prime example of the compelling storytelling prowess of Cold Case Files Classic, a show that will keep viewers on the edge of their seats from start to finish.