Plain Truth

Watch Plain Truth

"She doesn't trust outsiders. But an outsider is her only hope."
  • PG
  • 2004
  • 6.2  (958)

Plain Truth is a heart-wrenching drama that follows the story of Katie Fisher (Alison Pill), a young Amish woman who finds herself embroiled in a murder case in her own community. The movie, released in 2004, is based on the best-selling novel of the same name by Jodi Picoult. Katie Fisher lives with her family in an idyllic Amish community where everyone knows each other and lives a simple and peaceful life. However, one morning, the body of Katie's infant child is found in the barn, and suspicion immediately falls on her. She is arrested and charged with murder.

Enter Ellie Harrison (Mariska Hargitay), a high-powered Philadelphia lawyer who is assigned to defend Katie. Ellie, who is also struggling with personal issues of her own, is initially skeptical of Katie's claims of innocence. But as she immerses herself in the case, Ellie begins to uncover unsettling truths about the Amish community, and the case becomes more complicated than she ever imagined.

The movie builds up tension as the trial progresses, with the audience left wondering whether Katie will be convicted or acquitted. Along the way, viewers get a glimpse into the complexities of Amish life, which make it difficult for Katie to defend herself against the charges.

One of the standout performances in this movie is Alison Pill, who plays Katie Fisher. Pill beautifully captures both the innocence and strength of her character, as she navigates the challenges thrown at her. Mariska Hargitay, who plays Ellie Harrison, also delivers a standout performance, portraying the lawyer's personal struggles with depth and authenticity.

The supporting cast also shines in this movie. Jan Niklas, who plays Katie's father, is particularly noteworthy, as he delivers a heart-wrenching performance as a man grappling with the idea that his daughter might be guilty of something so heinous. Other actors, such as Kristen Dalton and Jonathan LaPaglia, also delivered strong performances that added to the overall quality of the movie.

The cinematography in Plain Truth is also noteworthy. The director, Paul Shapiro, does an excellent job of creating a haunting and evocative atmosphere that captures the essence of Amish life. The use of soft lighting, muted colors, and stark landscapes adds to the overall mood of the movie.

One of the most interesting aspects of Plain Truth is the exploration of the cultural differences between the Amish community and the secular world. The movie highlights how deeply rooted traditions and beliefs can make it difficult to understand or even communicate with people who are different.

Overall, Plain Truth is a thought-provoking movie that delves into complex themes such as faith, justice, and love. The movie's storytelling is gripping and emotionally charged, drawing the audience into the characters' lives and struggles. At its core, Plain Truth is a movie about confronting the truth, no matter how painful it may be.

Plain Truth
Plain Truth doesn't appear to be available from any streaming services.
Add this movie to your Watchlist to get notified when it's available.
  • Release Date
  • MPAA Rating
  • Language
  • IMDB Rating
    6.2  (958)