Watch The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story Podcast

Twenty years after the crime, Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik reckon with their action that Friday night in Pocatello. Why did Cassie have to die and was the right sentence given? In conversations and outtakes not included in the documentary, the killers, their parents, and psychopathy experts grapple with the quandary of life imprisonment for minors. Producers Conor and Pat weigh the arguments for and against, and shift the focus back to the victim, Cassie and a life tragically cut short.

Despite a videotape of damning evidence against them, Brian and Torey plead not guilty to Cassie's murder. Their trials commence and each boy pins the blame on the other with a life sentence hanging in the balance. Who was the leader and who was the follower? Is one boy more guilty than the other? 20 years after the crime, the killers tell Conor their own story in conversations never aired before.

A love of horror movies twisted into a real-life homicide: With Brian and Torey arrested for Cassie's death, their grand plans come to light. She was their first target, but she was not going to be the last. A kill list is discovered, the tape reveals a murderous rampage in motion, and 20 years later, Brian and Torey's intended victims tell their own stories.

16-Year-Old Brian Draper is accused of killing Cassie and Torey Adamcik has his own story for the investigators. But on a videotape buried in Black Rock Canyon, the shocking truth is waiting. Pat and Conor break down a chilling 30 minutes of VHS footage with additional material not aired in the Hulu documentary: What were Brian and Torey planning in the halls of Pocatello High School and where did it go off the rails? A prank gone wrong or two cold-blooded killers channeling their favorite Hollywood psycho?

Brian Draper's alibi starts to leak: Was he at the movies with Torey or somewhere else the night Cassie Stoddart was killed? Police dig in and discover a shocking videotape buried in the mountains above Pocatello that turns the whole case on its head. What happened in that house on the outskirts of town and was Cassie supposed to die? Pat Rogers and Conor McCarthy untangle the truth alongside Brian Draper's parents in exclusive interviews.

Pocatello, Idaho: 16-Year-Old Cassie Stoddart is dogsitting for her aunt and uncle on the outskirts of town. When they return on Sunday, Cassie is dead on the living room floor, stabbed 30 times. As fears of a serial killer rip through Pocatello, police track down the last three people to see Cassie alive: Her boyfriend Matt and high school friends, Brian and Torey. What did they see, what do they know, and are they telling the truth? Pat and Conor dive into the investigation.