Ep 6. Geronimo's Skull

In Brad Meltzer's Lost History season 1 episode 6, titled "Geronimo's Skull," Meltzer and his team investigate whether or not the skull of famous Apache leader Geronimo was really stolen from his grave by members of the secret society Skull and Bones at Yale University in the early 1900s. The controversy surrounding the alleged theft of Geronimo's skull has been a hotly debated issue for over a century, with many Native American groups and proponents of Indigenous rights demanding its return.

Meltzer, along with genealogist Carol Petranek and historian Keith Stattenfield, first visit the Yale University campus in search of clues that might point to the whereabouts of the skull. They explore the secretive world of Skull and Bones, an exclusive fraternity known for its powerful alumni, including several former US Presidents. Through interviews with current members and archival footage, Meltzer delves into the organization's ritualistic practices and attempts to uncover any evidence linking them to the alleged theft.

The team then travels to Oklahoma to meet with Harlyn Geronimo, the great-grandson of Geronimo, who has been fighting for the return of his ancestor's remains for decades. Harlyn is an articulate and passionate advocate for Indigenous rights and shares his family's story, including the details of Geronimo's capture and imprisonment by US forces. Meltzer listens intently and promises to do all he can to help bring the issue to light.

Next, Meltzer meets with several experts on Native American history and culture to gain a deeper understanding of the significance of Geronimo's skull to the Apache people. They explain the spiritual beliefs surrounding death and burial in Apache culture and how the theft of Geronimo's remains was a profound violation of those customs. Meltzer is visibly moved by their stories and vows to help bring justice to the Apache people.

The episode culminates in a dramatic confrontation between Meltzer and a representative from Skull and Bones at Yale University. Meltzer presents evidence that seems to link the group to the alleged theft of Geronimo's skull, including a letter from a former member boasting about the acquisition. The representative denies any knowledge of the theft and insists that the group has nothing to hide. Meltzer leaves frustrated but determined to continue his investigation and find a way to bring closure for the Geronimo family.

Throughout the episode, Meltzer and his team provide a balanced and thoughtful exploration of a complex and controversial issue. They approach the topic with sensitivity and respect, acknowledging the pain and trauma suffered by the Native American community. Their investigation highlights the importance of preserving cultural heritage and honoring the wishes of those whose ancestors have been wronged. Overall, "Geronimo's Skull" is a thought-provoking and emotionally charged episode that sheds light on an often-overlooked chapter in American history.