Nightmare Next Door

Watch Nightmare Next Door

  • 2011
  • 10 Seasons
  • 7.0  (1,074)

Nightmare Next Door is a crime investigation series that premiered on Investigation Discovery in 2011. The show focuses on harrowing real-life stories of crime, investigating shocking murders and homicide cases that occur in small towns and communities. The series features dramatized reenactments of the crimes, cutting-edge forensic investigation techniques, and interviews with victims' families, witnesses, and law enforcement officials. Each episode of the show delves into the dark secrets underlying seemingly peaceful and innocuous neighborhoods.

Greg Diefenbach, James Davenjay, and Dorian Lough serve as the presenters and narrators of the show, bringing a sense of urgency and gravitas to the proceedings. Their expert analysis and in-depth knowledge of forensic science offer viewers a fascinating look at how crimes are solved through technology and persistence.

One of the standout features of the show is its attention to detail. The Nightmare Next Door team is meticulous in reconstructing the crimes from evidence gathered by forensic professionals. The show's producers also place great emphasis on presenting an accurate portrayal of the investigations that took place, with interviews from the detectives involved and sometimes footage from the actual trials.

Each episode is structured around a particular crime or an unsolved mystery, with a focus on the people involved. The show narrows in on some of the most horrific homicides and violent attacks that have occurred in small, often idyllic and sleepy communities. As such, the show also serves as a warning and caution to viewers on the nature of crime.

The series begins by introducing the community where the crime took place and the victims. Through reenactments, viewers are given an insight into the lives of the families affected and how the crime occurred. The show then goes on to follow the police investigation – how did they gather evidence and what led them to the perpetrator. Here, the show also sheds light on how forensic science is used to catch criminals, offering an educational component to its true crime focus.

What sets the show apart from other true crime series is its unique take on cases that have been solved. While other series focus on the perpetrators, Nightmare Next Door looks at the impact of the crime on the community and the personal struggles of the victim's families. The show also includes interviews with the detectives involved and the forensic scientists who played a critical role in the crime's resolution. Without exploring the gruesome details, the show manages to maintain a sense of compassion and empathy for the victims' families.

The show's episodic structure also ensures that each story is distinct and captivating. From quintessential American small towns to seaside communities, each episode paints a picture of neighborhood life before and after a crime. The show looks at how the ripple effects of crime can reverberate far beyond the immediate family, affecting even the wider community.

Ultimately, The Nightmare Next Door is a gripping and intense true crime series that provides an insightful look into how scientists, forensic specialists, and detectives work together to solve crimes. The combination of in-depth research and a strong narrative makes the show compelling viewing, with its attention to detail and dramatic tone drawing viewers in.

In conclusion, Nightmare Next Door is a must-watch for true crime fans. It's well-produced, informative, and presents crime in a visceral yet respectful manner. The show is an excellent blend of educative and gripping content that showcases dedication to forensic science, precision, and diligence of law enforcement officials. It offers an insight into the criminal mind and, most of all, the healing that is required for those left behind when a loved one is taken.

Nightmare Next Door is a series that is currently running and has 10 seasons (109 episodes). The series first aired on January 6, 2011.

Nightmare Next Door
Filter by Source

Episode 11
11. Episode 11
November 11, 2016
Summary not available
A Strange Trust
10. A Strange Trust
November 4, 2016
When 16-year-old BFFs Dawn Donaldson and Crissy Campbell vanish overnight, the residents of Grass Valley, California, fear for their children's safety. Rumors fly, from runaways to abduction. Detectives must find them before their worst fears come true.
Only The Good
9. Only The Good
October 28, 2016
In suburban Tennessee, Jimmy McClain is living a good life as a teacher and coach at a local high school. But early one February morning, police find him murdered in his home. With a long list of suspects, whose motive is strong enough to want him dead?
Everyone Has A Motive
8. Everyone Has A Motive
October 21, 2016
When John Kowalczyk is shot dead, rumors fly in the quiet town of Vienna, VA. Friends can’t imagine who would murder the successful entrepreneur. But as police look into John’s inner circle, a web of suspects emerges that has the whole town on edge.
The Art of Murder
7. The Art of Murder
October 14, 2016
When Shelley Nance is found stabbed to death, the shocking murder sends the community of Lake Highlands, TX into a panic. Friends are stunned as police zero in on her closest friends. What they uncover is jealousy, hate, and a bizarre fatal attraction.
Sex, Money & Murder
6. Sex, Money & Murder
October 7, 2016
Lance Herndon was living the American dream in Roswell GA, until the millionaire is found brutally murdered. While this upper class town is reeling from the vicious killing, behind the gates of their upscale communities – investigators find a twisted web
Death Takes a Toll
5. Death Takes a Toll
September 30, 2016
New England business owner Michael Zammitti Jr is found shot to death at his desk.
Criss-Cross Killer
4. Criss-Cross Killer
September 23, 2016
Examining the murder of a woman who was killed in the living room of her Nashville home.
Dear Katherine, It's Me the Killer
3. Dear Katherine, It's Me the Killer
September 16, 2016
Investigating the disappearance of an 18-year-old freshman from the University of South Alabama.
The Unwelcome Wagon
2. The Unwelcome Wagon
September 9, 2016
When Staff Sgt. Michael Severance goes AWOL the community of San Angelo rallies around his new bride. But there is something more sinister behind his disappearance, and investigators uncover a saga of treachery and passion as big as the state of Texas.
The Key to Murder
1. The Key to Murder
September 2, 2016
Melinda Snyder's death stunned Rock Hill, SC, where even her closest friends came into question. The former homecoming queen's murder embroiled the quiet town in a mystery that wouldn't be settled until the South Carolina Supreme Court weighed in.
Where to Watch Nightmare Next Door
Nightmare Next Door is available for streaming on the Investigation Discovery website, both individual episodes and full seasons. You can also watch Nightmare Next Door on demand at Max, Discovery+, Amazon Prime, Amazon, Vudu, Investigation Discovery, FuboTV, Sling, Google Play, Apple TV and Tubi TV.
  • Premiere Date
    January 6, 2011
  • IMDB Rating
    7.0  (1,074)