Ep 5. The Suspects

The Keepers Season 1 Episode 5: The Suspects

The Keepers is a gripping true crime documentary series that explores the unsolved murder of Sister Cathy Cesnik, a beloved nun and teacher in Baltimore who disappeared in 1969. The series follows a group of former students of Sister Cathy, who have been investigating her murder for decades, as they uncover a web of secrets and corruption involving the Catholic Church and the police department.

In episode 5, titled "The Suspects," the team focuses on two main suspects in the case - Father Joseph Maskell, who was accused by several women of sexual abuse when he was a counselor at Archbishop Keough High School, where Sister Cathy taught, and Edgar Davidson, a former police officer who was involved in a group of officers known as the 'Knights of Columbus' that operated in the area.

The team speaks to several of Maskell's alleged victims, who describe him as a terrifying and manipulative figure who abused his power in the church and preyed on vulnerable young women. They also speak to a former student who claims to have witnessed Maskell and another man carrying a large object out of the school late at night around the time of Sister Cathy's disappearance.

As for Davidson, the team learns that his son was in a relationship with a girl who attended Archbishop Keough High School at the same time as Sister Cathy and was also a victim of sexual abuse by Maskell. They also uncover evidence that Davidson may have been involved in a cover-up of the murder, including tampering with evidence and intimidating witnesses.

Throughout the episode, the team presents various theories about what happened to Sister Cathy, including the possibility that she was killed because she knew about the sexual abuse at the school and was going to speak out. They also delve deeper into the connection between the church and the police department, and how this may have given certain individuals the power to evade justice.

Overall, "The Suspects" is a chilling and thought-provoking episode that sheds new light on the complex web of secrets and corruption that surrounded Sister Cathy's murder. It highlights the bravery and determination of the former students who have been fighting for justice for over five decades, and leaves the viewer eager to learn more about this captivating and tragic case.