I Think You're Totally Wrong: A Quarrel

Watch I Think You're Totally Wrong: A Quarrel

  • NR
  • 2014
  • 1 hr 28 min
  • 6.9  (84)

I Think You're Totally Wrong: A Quarrel is a thought-provoking film that explores the complexities of friendship, marriage, and the pursuit of happiness. Based on the book of the same name by David Shields and Caleb Powell, the film follows their real-life debate over the merits of art, marriage, and life itself. The film begins with Powell (played by himself) inviting his long-time friend, Shields (played by James Franco), to his cabin in the woods for a weekend of conversation and debate. The two have been friends for years, but have grown apart in recent years due to their differing philosophies on life. Powell, a self-proclaimed acolyte of David Foster Wallace, believes in the transformative power of art and literature, while Shields, an accomplished novelist, is skeptical of such claims and prefers a more pragmatic approach to life.

The weekend soon devolves into a heated argument, with both men pushing each other to the brink of their patience and sanity. They spar over everything from the purpose of marriage to the merits of pornography, with neither willing to concede any ground to the other. Their wives, who are present at the cabin, watch on in amusement and horror as the two men continue their debate long into the night.

Despite the tension, the film is punctuated with moments of levity and introspection. We see the two men enjoying a scenic hike in the woods, reminiscing about their past and pondering their future. We also see them engaging in solo pursuits, with Powell penning a semi-autobiographical novel and Shields tinkering with an experimental film project.

As the film reaches its conclusion, both men seem to have reached a sort of truce. They agree to disagree, but not before recognizing the value of their dialogue and the bonds of friendship that have kept them together all these years.

The film is shot in a documentary style, with handheld cameras and natural lighting adding a sense of authenticity to the proceedings. The performances are raw and unfiltered, with Franco and Powell bickering and bantering with an almost improvisational flair.

In many ways, the film feels like a love letter to intellectual discourse and the art of conversation. It's a reminder that healthy disagreement is essential to the human experience, and that true friendship can endure even the most trying of circumstances.

Overall, I Think You're Totally Wrong: A Quarrel is a must-see for anyone who appreciates a good debate or a well-crafted film. It's a film that will challenge your assumptions and leave you pondering the nature of existence long after the credits have rolled.

I Think You're Totally Wrong: A Quarrel
I Think You're Totally Wrong: A Quarrel doesn't appear to be available from any streaming services.
Add this movie to your Watchlist to get notified when it's available.
  • Release Date
  • MPAA Rating
  • Runtime
    1 hr 28 min
  • Language
  • IMDB Rating
    6.9  (84)