Watch These Three

These Three (1936) is a compelling drama set in an all-girls school that explores the power of lies, deceit, and betrayal of trust. Adapted from Lillian Hellman's 1934 play, The Children's Hour, the film is directed by the renowned William Wyler and features an ensemble cast of talented actors, including Merle Oberon, Miriam Hopkins, and Joel McCrea. The plot revolves around Martha Dobie (Hopkins) and Karen Wright (Oberon), two schoolteachers who operate a girls' boarding school. The two women have been friends since childhood and conduct their school with a shared sense of purpose and dedication. The story begins when a mischievous student, Mary Tilford (Bonita Granville), spreads a rumor that Martha and Karen are having a romantic relationship. When Mary is caught in a lie and punished, she retaliates by accusing the two women of engaging in a same-sex relationship. With no evidence to support their innocence, the story quickly spreads throughout the school, leading to a cascade of events that threatens to destroy Martha and Karen's reputations. As the rumors intensify, Martha begins to lose control and eventually confesses her love for Karen, further solidifying Mary's accusations. When the parents of the girls at the school find out, they pull their daughters out, leaving the school on the verge of bankruptcy. The third character in the triangle is Dr. Joseph Cardin (McCrea), a handsome young man who is in love with Karen. He tries to help Karen and Martha clear their names and restore their reputation. However, tensions rise between the three central characters as the truth ultimately comes to light. Throughout the movie, Wyler masterfully captures the internal struggles of the central characters who are trapped in the web of lies and deceit. The film powerfully conveys the themes of bullying, betrayal, and loyalty, and the consequences of lies and rumors. The brilliant performances by the actors bring the material to life. Hopkins plays Martha with a level of intensity and vulnerability that makes her an empathetic figure. Oberon gives an understated performance as Karen, balancing the pain of betrayal with the need to protect the reputation of the school. McCrea brings a sense of charm and nobility to the role of Dr. Cardin, even as his character veers towards moral ambiguity. Undeniably, a standout performance is delivered by Bonita Granville as Mary Tilford. She portrays a complex and manipulative character with such depth and nuance that, at times, the viewer sympathizes with her despite her actions. Her ability to stir up the emotions of the other characters while hiding her own inner desires drives the plot forward and sets the stage for one of the most compelling scenes in the film. The production design of These Three is also noteworthy, with settings that create texture and atmosphere in every scene. The film's use of visual storytelling through camera angles, lighting, and costumes adds layers of meaning to the story, making it an aesthetically satisfying experience. In summary, These Three is a poignant film that is as relevant today as it was when it was first released. It explores deep human emotions and the consequences of rumors and deceit with intelligence, compassion, and insight. With masterful direction, evocative cinematography, and powerful performances from its cast, These Three is a must-see for fans of classic cinema.