Ep 5. Kimberly Mays: Switched at Birth

Barbara Walters Presents American Scandals is a true-crime documentary series that delves into some of the most notorious scandals in American history. In season 1 episode 5, entitled "Kimberly Mays: Switched at Birth," the show explores the haunting case of two babies who were mistakenly switched at birth, and the devastating consequences that followed.

The episode takes us back to 1978, when two Florida women, Ernestine Twigg and Regina Twigg, gave birth to baby girls at the same hospital, within hours of each other. The two women, who had never met before, were both given their newborns to take home, believing they were theirs. However, shortly after they left the hospital, they started to notice some peculiarities about their daughters that led them to question whether the babies had been switched.

As the episode unfolds, we see how Ernestine and Regina tried to raise their daughters, despite their suspicions about the mix-up. We learn about the growing tension between the families, and the legal battle that ensued when the truth finally came to light. We also hear from Kimberly Mays herself, who talks about the emotional toll that this shocking revelation had on her and her family.

The episode is both heart-wrenching and compelling, as it delves into the complex issues that arose from this tragedy. Viewers will be both horrified and moved by the story of these two families, and the struggles they endured in the aftermath of the mix-up. With narration from Barbara Walters and interviews with key witnesses and experts, this episode of American Scandals is a must-see for anyone interested in true-crime stories and the human consequences of tragic mistakes.