Ep 2. Between The Truth

The Case Against Adnan Syed is a true crime docuseries that focuses on the murder of Hae Min Lee, a popular high school student who was found strangled in a Baltimore park in 1999. Her ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed, was convicted of the crime and has maintained his innocence for over two decades. Season 1 episode 2 is titled "Between The Truth" and explores the inconsistencies in witness testimonies and cell phone records that were presented during Adnan's trial.

The episode begins with a closer look at the timeline of events leading up to Hae Min Lee's disappearance. Adnan's friend, Jay, who was a key witness in the trial, claimed that Adnan showed him Hae's body in the trunk of his car on the day of the murder. However, details surrounding Jay's involvement in the crime and the accuracy of his statements have been called into question. Private investigator, Colin Miller, delves deeper into Jay's story and uncovers discrepancies that suggest his testimony may not have been entirely truthful.

The episode also explores the role of cell phone records in Adnan's conviction. Prosecutor Kevin Urick argued that cell phone tower pings placed Adnan near the site of Hae's burial. However, defense attorney Rabia Chaudry argues that the technology used to determine tower locations was unreliable and could not accurately place Adnan at the crime scene. The episode features interviews with experts in the field of cell phone forensics who provide insight into the limitations of this type of evidence.

The episode also introduces new information about the case, such as the fact that another student, Don, who was Hae's boyfriend at the time of her murder, was at work during the time when the prosecution claims Hae was killed. Don was initially considered a suspect in the case but was later ruled out. The documentary team speaks with Don, who provides his own perspective on the investigation.

Throughout the episode, Adnan's family and friends express their belief in his innocence and their frustration with the justice system. Adnan's former classmate and close friend, Saad Chaudry, suggests that Adnan was targeted by law enforcement because of his race and religion. He also points out that Adnan's defense team was underfunded and did not have access to the same resources as the prosecution.

Overall, "Between The Truth" raises important questions about the validity of witness testimony and the methods used to gather and analyze evidence in criminal trials. The episode provides new information and insights into the case against Adnan Syed, highlighting the complexity and nuance of this ongoing investigation.