Ep 3. Water Foul

Your Worst Nightmare Season 1 Episode 3, "Water Foul," delves into the story of a woman named Ann Marie Hohenberger. She is a mother of two who moves to Tampa Bay, Florida, with her husband Jeff to start a new life and a new business. Ann Marie is excited to make new friends and explore her new hometown.

One day, while kayaking with her mother-in-law, Carol, Ann Marie is approached by a man named Gary Michael Hilton. He is a rugged-looking hiker who seems friendly enough. He tells them that he knows these waters well and offers to take them to a secluded beach where they can have a picnic.

Ann Marie and Carol are hesitant at first, but Gary seems charming and knowledgeable, so they agree to follow him. However, things quickly take a dark turn when they arrive at a deserted area. Gary pulls out a knife and attacks the women. Ann Marie fights back but is eventually overpowered.

The episode then retraces the events leading up to Ann Marie's attack, from the moment she meets Gary to her abduction and murder. Interviews with family members, law enforcement, and experts on such cases, provide insights into the mind of a killer and how to avoid becoming a victim.

Throughout the episode, viewers are shown different scenarios of how the tragedy could have been avoided and how to defend oneself in extreme situations. In particular, viewers are warned about the dangers of trusting strangers and the importance of situational awareness.

As the episode progresses, we learn how the investigation unfolds, including the search for Ann Marie's body and the apprehension of her killer. One of the key pieces of evidence is her kayak, which was found abandoned in the same area where she was last seen.

The investigators, led by Detective Bobby Lovett, follow a trail of clues that eventually lead them to Hilton, who has a history of violent behavior. Interviews with experts reveal how Hilton's crimes fit the profile of a serial killer and how he used his knowledge of the wilderness to avoid detection.

In the end, justice is served as Hilton is convicted of Ann Marie's murder, as well as a string of other violent crimes. The episode ends with a cautionary message to always be aware of your surroundings and to never let your guard down, even in the most seemingly safe places.

"Water Foul" is a gripping and haunting episode that will leave viewers with a greater appreciation for the importance of personal safety. It serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us that danger can lurk in even the most ordinary of situations. Viewers will be captivated by the tale of Ann Marie and the brave investigators who helped bring her killer to justice.