Ep 3. Devil's Advocate

In the season 4 episode 3 of A Crime to Remember, titled "Devil's Advocate," viewers are taken back to the 1960s, where a string of seemingly random crimes is plaguing the city of Boston. However, it soon becomes clear that these crimes are not random at all, but rather the work of a cunning and highly intelligent serial killer.

The episode begins with the discovery of the first victim, a young woman found strangled in her apartment. As more bodies start to turn up, investigators scramble to find any connections between the victims, hoping to find a lead that will help them track down the killer.

As they delve deeper into the case, they discover that all of the victims were young women who had recently moved to the city to start new lives. They also find that many of them had been attending meetings at a local church, where they had come into contact with a man named William Mentzer.

Mentzer is a charismatic figure who has a way of drawing people in with his charm and eloquence. He is also a self-proclaimed expert on demonology, which he uses to convince his followers that he has a special connection to the supernatural world.

The investigators soon become convinced that Mentzer is the killer they are looking for. However, they have no concrete evidence to link him to the crimes, and he seems to have a perfect alibi for each of the murders.

As the investigation drags on, tensions begin to mount between the police and the public, with many people accusing the authorities of not doing enough to catch the killer. Meanwhile, Mentzer continues to preach his twisted version of Christianity, drawing in new followers and further obscuring the truth.

Ultimately, it is a combination of luck and good police work that finally leads to the arrest of William Mentzer. But even as he is taken into custody, questions remain about his true motivations and the nature of the evil that drove him to commit such heinous acts.

Throughout the episode, viewers are treated to a fascinating and often chilling glimpse into the mind of a serial killer, as well as the social and cultural context that allowed him to thrive. With its expertly crafted storytelling and stylish recreation of the era, "Devil's Advocate" is a must-watch for true crime fans and anyone interested in the psychology of violent crime.