Ep 4. Whose History?

In the season 2, episode 4 of America Divided, titled Whose History?, the show tackles the controversial issue of Confederate monuments and their place in American history. The episode explores the ongoing debate about whether these monuments should be removed or preserved as important historical markers.

The episode begins with a focus on New Orleans, where the controversial removal of Confederate statues has caused intense debate and protests. We hear from residents on both sides of the issue, including those who believe these monuments are an important part of their heritage and those who see them as symbols of racism and oppression.

Next, the show takes us to Richmond, Virginia, where the debate over Confederate monuments is equally heated. We hear from students at a local high school who are advocating for the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee that stands in front of their school. They argue that it is inappropriate for a school named after a civil rights leader to have a Confederate statue as its centerpiece.

We then meet historian Ed Ayers, who offers some context for the debate over Confederate monuments. He explains that these statues were not erected after the Civil War as a way to honor fallen soldiers; rather, they were put up in the early 20th century as a way to celebrate the Confederacy and reinforce white supremacy.

The episode also explores the idea of alternative monuments that could be erected in place of Confederate statues. We hear from artist Kehinde Wiley, who has created a series of monuments featuring contemporary black subjects in heroic poses. He argues that these new monuments would help to create a more inclusive and diverse vision of American history.

Finally, the episode turns its attention to the broader question of how we remember and commemorate our collective history. We hear from Congressman John Lewis, who reflects on the importance of the Civil Rights Movement and the struggle to create a more just and equitable society. He argues that we must confront the darker parts of our history in order to move forward as a nation.

Overall, Whose History? is a thought-provoking and insightful exploration of a contentious issue that continues to divide Americans. Through interviews with historians, artists, and ordinary citizens, the episode offers a nuanced perspective on the debate over Confederate monuments and the broader question of how we remember our past.