Ep 2. The Smith Sisters

In the second episode of I, Witness season 1, viewers are introduced to the Smith sisters, two women who were convicted of killing their mother's ex-boyfriend in May of 1998. The episode begins with a brief overview of the crime, which took place in a small town in Pennsylvania, before diving into the details of the case.

The Smith sisters, Misty and Kari, were teenagers when they were arrested for the murder of Brian Lewis, a man who had dated their mother for a short time. According to authorities, the sisters lured Lewis to a remote location where they shot him multiple times before dumping his body in a nearby river. The case quickly gained national attention, with many people speculating about the possible motives behind the sisters' actions.

Using interviews with family members, law enforcement officials, and legal experts, the episode examines the evidence presented in the case and the various theories surrounding the sisters' motivations. Some believe that Misty and Kari acted out of self-defense, saying that Lewis had been physically abusive towards them and their mother. Others argue that the sisters were influenced by a group of friends who had a fascination with murder and violence.

The episode also delves into the legal proceedings that followed the sisters' arrest. Misty and Kari were ultimately convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. However, there were questions about the fairness of their trial, with some claiming that the prosecution used misleading tactics to secure a guilty verdict.

Throughout the episode, viewers are given a detailed look into the lives of Misty and Kari before and after the murder. Family members describe the sisters as loving and affectionate, while others share stories about their troubled personal lives and struggles with addiction. The episode also includes interviews with Misty and Kari themselves, who speak candidly about their experiences and reflect on the events that led to their conviction.

Overall, The Smith Sisters offers a compelling look into a controversial case that continues to raise questions about the American legal system. By exploring the perspectives of various individuals involved in the case, the episode provides a nuanced and thought-provoking examination of the factors that can influence the outcome of a criminal trial.