Ep 5. Twist of Faith

True Crime with Aphrodite Jones is a true crime documentary series that explores some of the most infamous and mysterious crimes in the United States. In season 2 episode 5, titled Twist of Faith, Jones delves into the shocking story of an Ohio family torn apart by a brutal murder.

The episode opens with a glimpse of the picturesque and peaceful small town of Wapakoneta, where the Fisher family lived. On a hot July night in 2011, the town was shaken to its core when the body of 26-year-old Ryan Fisher was found in a pool of blood in his garage. His wife, Nicole Fisher, had discovered him when she came home from work, and screamed for help.

As the investigation unfolded, it became clear that Ryan had been brutally beaten and stabbed multiple times, and his killer had left behind a glove and a bloody footprint. The police interviewed Nicole, but she had an alibi and no motive to kill her husband, who was a well-liked firefighter and paramedic. The detectives also talked to the couple's close friends and family, but no one had any leads or suspicions.

Jones interviews the lead investigator in the case, Detective Mark Delaney, who admits that the case was baffling from the start. She also talks to Ryan's parents, Kevin and Vicki Fisher, who describe their shock and grief upon hearing the news of their son's murder. They had been close to Nicole, who they saw as their daughter-in-law, but now they were struggling to understand what had happened to their son and why.

As Jones digs deeper into the case, she discovers a web of secrets and lies that had been hiding in plain sight. Ryan had been a devout Christian, and one of his close friends was a charismatic youth pastor named Hennon Lee. Lee had been a mentor and confidant to Ryan, and had even officiated at his wedding to Nicole. However, as Jones investigates, she uncovers evidence that Lee had been having an affair with Nicole, and that Ryan had confronted them about it.

This revelation leads to a shocking twist in the case, and raises questions about the motives of the killer. Was the murder a crime of passion, with Nicole and Lee teaming up to eliminate Ryan? Or was it a tragic accident, with Nicole hiring someone to scare Ryan, only for things to spiral out of control?

As Jones pieces together the evidence and talks to those who knew the Fishers and Lee, she uncovers a complex and tragic story of love, faith, and betrayal. Twist of Faith is a gripping and emotional episode that highlights the devastating consequences of secrets and deceit in a small town community.