Ep 4. Mother Daughter Tragedy (Fort Wayne, IN)

In Cold Justice season 3 episode 4 titled "Mother Daughter Tragedy(Fort Wayne, IN)," former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and her team investigate a cold case involving a mother and daughter who were brutally murdered in their home over 30 years ago.

The episode begins with Siegler and her team arriving in Fort Wayne, Indiana, to investigate the unsolved murders of 43-year-old Diane Tilly and her 15-year-old daughter, Whitney. The two were beaten to death with a hammer and left in their home for two days before they were discovered. Despite the brutal nature of the crime, the case has remained unsolved for more than three decades.

Siegler and her team begin by interviewing family members, friends, and neighbors of the victims. They quickly discover that Diane had multiple extramarital affairs and that her husband had a history of abuse. They also learn that Whitney had been sexually abused by someone close to her.

As the team delves deeper into the case, they uncover a web of secrets and lies. One suspect emerges as a possible killer, but his alibi proves to be ironclad. Another suspect, a former neighbor of the Tillys, becomes a person of interest when it's revealed that he had been stalking Whitney prior to her death.

The team also re-interviews witnesses from the original investigation and uncovers new information that leads them to a breakthrough in the case. They bring this evidence to the local prosecutor's office, who agrees to present a case to a grand jury.

Throughout the episode, the team faces challenges, including difficulty finding witnesses who are willing to talk and difficulty obtaining information from the original investigation. But through diligent investigative work and perseverance, they are able to bring new life to the cold case and, hopefully, bring justice to the victims and their families.

Overall, "Mother Daughter Tragedy" is a gripping episode of Cold Justice that showcases the team's tireless efforts to bring closure to a decades-old case. With surprising twists and turns, the episode keeps viewers on the edge of their seats as Siegler and her team uncover new information that could finally solve the case.