Ep 11. If a Tree Falls: A Story of the Earth Liberation Front by Marshall Curry

If a Tree Falls: A Story of the Earth Liberation Front is the eleventh episode in the twenty-fourth season of POV, a documentary series that showcases poignant and thought-provoking stories from around the world. This episode, directed by Marshall Curry, explores the controversial actions of the radical environmental group known as the Earth Liberation Front (ELF).

The film follows the journey of Daniel McGowan, a former member of the ELF who was arrested and charged with multiple acts of arson committed by the group. Through interviews with McGowan and his family, as well as other members of the group and law enforcement officials, the documentary delves into the motivations behind the group's actions and the impact they had on those involved.

The film begins by introducing the audience to McGowan, who is currently serving a 7-year sentence for his involvement with the ELF. Through interviews with his family, including his sister and mother, viewers learn about McGowan's past and what drove him to become involved in the group. The film then goes on to explore the history of the ELF, including their early actions against animal testing and logging, and their eventual shift towards using more aggressive tactics such as arson.

Throughout the film, Curry presents a balanced and nuanced portrayal of both sides of the story. On one hand, he showcases the passion and commitment of the ELF members, who saw themselves as fighting against a corrupt and oppressive system that prioritized profit over the environment. On the other hand, he also presents the point of view of law enforcement officials and the victims of the group's actions, who saw them as terrorists who were causing harm and endangering lives.

One of the most powerful aspects of the film is the way it explores the personal toll that the ELF's actions had on those involved. For McGowan and many other members of the group, their involvement led to arrests, imprisonment, and shattered relationships with family and friends. The film also highlights the impact that the group's actions had on the environment and the communities affected by their actions, including the destruction of personal property, job loss, and emotional trauma.

Overall, If a Tree Falls: A Story of the Earth Liberation Front is a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant documentary that raises important questions about the balance between environmental activism and the rule of law. Through its exploration of the ELF's motivations and actions, the film challenges viewers to consider the complex ethical and moral issues at play in the fight for environmental justice.