Ep 4. House by the Lake

In American Crime Story Season 2, Episode 4 titled "House by the Lake," viewers witness the continued unraveling of Andrew Cunanan's psyche as he struggles to maintain his facade of wealth and power while hiding from the law. The episode takes us back to December 1995, when Cunanan arrives in Minneapolis to visit an old friend, Jeff Trail.

As Cunanan reconnects with Trail and meets Trail's new friend, David Madson, the trio's careful dance around each other sets an ominous tone. Cunanan's desperate need to be seen as important and wealthy becomes increasingly apparent as he manipulates those around him, trying to maintain a sense of control.

The scenes at the titular House by the Lake are both tense and contemplative as the three men navigate their complicated relationships and histories. Cunanan basks in the luxurious surroundings, hoping they will give the impression that he is still as successful as he portrays himself. The tension builds as Trail confronts Cunanan about his lies and delusions, and the facade begins to crumble.

As the episode progresses, Cunanan's grip on reality weakens, and viewers are drawn further into his twisted mind. The scenes with Madson and Cunanan's interactions with Trail are no longer tense—they're downright uncomfortable. Cunanan's erratic behavior and growing paranoia make it clear that something is about to give.

The sound design of "House by the Lake" heightens the sense of unease throughout the episode. The score is tense and brooding, and there are moments when the scene cuts to silence, amplifying the tension of what's happening onscreen.

Overall, "House by the Lake" is a chilling yet masterfully executed episode of American Crime Story. The script, acting, and direction all work together to create a deeply unsettling experience that leaves viewers anticipating the inevitable destruction to come.