Ep 5. Clair Hour 1: Black or White

In the fifth episode of season 2 of the true-crime documentary series, Wrong Man, we are introduced to the case of Clair, a woman who was accused and convicted of murdering her neighbor in 1984. Over the course of this hour-long episode, we follow the investigation team as they delve into the case and attempt to uncover the truth behind her conviction.

The episode begins with an introduction to Clair's case - she was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison for allegedly shooting and killing her neighbor, a man named Timothy, during a heated argument. Although there were no eyewitnesses to the crime, a woman named Renee claimed to have seen Clair walking away from the scene of the crime with a gun in her hand. This evidence, along with a few other key pieces of information, was enough to convict her.

As the investigation team begins to dig deeper into the case, they quickly find a number of inconsistencies and discrepancies in the evidence presented at the trial. For example, Renee's story seems to have changed multiple times over the years, and there are several inconsistencies in the way she describes what she saw on the night in question. Additionally, there are questions about the physical evidence - although there were bullet holes found in Timothy's apartment, there was no gunpowder residue found on Clair's hands or clothing.

As the team continues to investigate, they also begin to uncover some alternate theories about what might have happened on the night of the murder. For example, some witnesses have stated that they saw another man in the area around the time of the crime who looked similar to Clair. Could it be possible that this man was the real killer? Other theories involve a drug deal gone wrong, or a dispute over a gambling debt.

Throughout the episode, we get to know Clair herself, as well as some of her friends and family members who have been fighting for her release for years. We hear about her difficult upbringing, her struggles with addiction, and the abusive relationship she was in at the time of the murder. We also see the toll that her incarceration has taken on her loved ones, who continue to fight for her release even decades later.

The investigation team also speaks to several experts in the fields of forensics, ballistics, and eyewitness testimony. These experts shed light on some of the flaws and weaknesses in the evidence presented at the trial, and offer suggestions for how the team might be able to uncover more information to help exonerate Clair.

Overall, this episode of Wrong Man is a compelling and emotional look at a case that has been shrouded in mystery and controversy for over three decades. Through interviews with those involved in the case, as well as expert analysis of the evidence, the team attempts to uncover the truth behind Clair's conviction, and to shed light on the flaws and biases that can sometimes lead to wrongful convictions in the justice system.

In the end, viewers are left with several questions and theories about what really happened on the night of Timothy's murder, and an intense sense of anticipation for the next episode.