Ep 5. Digging for Answers

In the fifth episode of the sixth season of Cold Justice titled "Digging for Answers", former prosecutor Kelly Siegler and former crime scene investigator Yolanda McClary travel to the small town of Poteau, Oklahoma to investigate the case of a missing woman named Melissa Witt. Melissa was only 19 years old when she disappeared on December 1, 1994, from the parking lot of a convenience store where she had gone to buy Christmas gifts for her family. Her mother last saw her when she dropped Melissa off at the store, but when she returned a few minutes later, Melissa was nowhere to be found.

The case immediately became a high-profile one with a lot of media attention, but despite a massive search effort and countless tips, Melissa's whereabouts remained unknown. The police investigated several suspects, including a local man named Karl Fontenot who was already in prison for another murder, but they were never able to bring anyone to justice.

Kelly and Yolanda take a fresh look at the case decades later and begin by reviewing the evidence that was collected at the time. They interview Melissa's family and friends, as well as several people who were considered suspects. They also look into the possibility of a connection between Melissa's case and other unsolved cases in the area.

As they dig deeper, Kelly and Yolanda uncover new leads and evidence that had been overlooked or dismissed by the police. They also encounter a lot of resistance from some of the people they interview, including witnesses who are reluctant to talk and suspects who deny any involvement. However, they remain focused on finding the truth and bringing justice to Melissa and her family.

Throughout the episode, Kelly and Yolanda provide insights into their investigation techniques and the challenges of investigating a cold case. They discuss the importance of using technology to re-examine old evidence and the value of interviewing witnesses and suspects face-to-face. They also highlight the emotional toll of working on cases like Melissa's, both on themselves and on the families of the victims.

In the end, Kelly and Yolanda make significant progress in the case and uncover some shocking new information that could finally lead to Melissa's killer being brought to justice. The episode ends on a cliffhanger, leaving viewers eager to see how the investigation will unfold in the next episode.

Overall, "Digging for Answers" is a gripping and emotional episode of Cold Justice that highlights the importance of never giving up on finding the truth, no matter how old or seemingly unsolvable a case may seem. With their expertise and dedication, Kelly and Yolanda prove that even the coldest cases can be cracked with the right tools and approach.