Judge Mathis Season 18 Episode 39 Episode 39

In Episode 39 of Judge Mathis season 18, Judge Greg Mathis presides over another day of small claims court cases. The cases range from a landlord-tenant dispute to a dispute over a damaged vehicle, showcasing a variety of legal issues that the judge must address.

The first case focuses on a tenant who is being sued by their landlord for unpaid rent. The tenant argues that the landlord refused to make necessary repairs to the property, which made it impossible for them to live there and pay full rent. The landlord claims that the tenant did not communicate these concerns and that they are owed the full amount of rent. Judge Mathis must determine whether the landlord's actions constituted a breach of contract and whether the tenant has the right to withhold rent.

The second case involves a disagreement between two friends over a damaged car. One friend allegedly crashed the car and owes the other friend money for repairs. However, the defendant claims that the damage was not his fault and that the plaintiff is trying to cheat him out of money. Judge Mathis must determine who is responsible for the damage and whether the plaintiff is entitled to compensation.

The third case revolves around a dispute between roommates over the division of household expenses. The plaintiff argues that the defendant did not contribute his fair share of the rent and other expenses, causing her financial hardship. The defendant claims that he contributed what he could and that the plaintiff is exaggerating the situation. Judge Mathis must determine whether the defendant failed to fulfill his financial obligations and whether the plaintiff is entitled to compensation.

The fourth case involves a disagreement between a homeowner and a contracting company over the quality of work performed on the home. The plaintiff argues that the contractor did a poor job and failed to complete necessary repairs, which caused significant financial harm. The contractor claims that they completed the work as promised and that the plaintiff is being unreasonable. Judge Mathis must determine whether the contractor fulfilled their obligations and whether the plaintiff is entitled to compensation for any damages incurred.

The final case of the episode features a dispute between a landlord and a tenant over damage to a rental property. The landlord claims that the tenant caused significant damage to the property and owes thousands of dollars in repairs. The tenant argues that the damage was pre-existing and that the landlord is trying to take advantage of him. Judge Mathis must determine the extent of the damage and whether the tenant is responsible for any repairs.

Throughout the episode, Judge Mathis listens to arguments from both sides and evaluates evidence to determine the best outcome for each case. He also offers advice for future conflicts and instructs both parties on their legal rights and responsibilities. Overall, Episode 39 of Judge Mathis season 18 offers a glimpse into the varied legal issues that can arise in small claims court and the importance of seeking legal resolution to disputes.