Judge Mathis Season 19 Episode 38 Episode 38

In episode 38 of Judge Mathis season 19, viewers are taken into the courtroom where Judge Greg Mathis presides over a case involving a dispute between two former friends. The plaintiff, a young woman named Jessica, is suing her former friend and landlord, Chelsea, for allegedly withholding her security deposit. According to Jessica, she had lived in one of Chelsea's rental properties and had left it in a clean and undamaged state. However, Chelsea had refused to return her security deposit despite several requests.

Chelsea, on the other hand, claims that Jessica had damaged the property and had failed to pay her rent in full, which is why she was withholding the deposit. She argues that she had provided Jessica with an itemized bill of the damages and unpaid rent, and that Jessica had not disputed or paid it.

As the trial begins, Judge Mathis listens to both sides of the story and asks each party to present their evidence. Jessica shows the judge several pictures of the property taken before she moved in and after she left, which show no significant differences in the condition of the property. She also brings in two witnesses who testify to the fact that Jessica had left the property in good condition and had paid her rent in full.

Chelsea, on the other hand, presents her own set of pictures as evidence, which she claims show the damages caused by Jessica and the unpaid rent. However, Judge Mathis notices that the pictures lack a date and time stamp, making it difficult to verify their authenticity. He also questions why Chelsea had not documented the damages immediately after they occurred and why she had not brought up the unpaid rent earlier.

After reviewing all the evidence presented by both parties, Judge Mathis delivers his verdict. He finds in favor of Jessica and orders Chelsea to return her security deposit. He concludes that the evidence presented by Jessica and her witnesses, along with the lack of credible evidence from Chelsea, made it clear that Jessica had not caused any damages nor had she left the property in a bad condition. He also notes that the lack of documentation and the delay in raising rent concerns made it difficult to believe Chelsea's claims.

In addition to deciding the case, Judge Mathis takes the opportunity to remind both parties of the importance of maintaining a good landlord-tenant relationship. He advises Chelsea to take proper steps to document damages and rent-related issues in the future, and instructs Jessica to ensure that she pays her rent in full and avoids any actions that can damage the property.

Overall, episode 38 of Judge Mathis season 19 showcases the judge's expertise in handling disputes between individuals and highlights the importance of presenting credible evidence in court. It also serves as a reminder of the importance of maintaining good relationships between landlords and tenants.