Judge Mathis Season 19 Episode 5 Episode 5

Judge Mathis is a popular daytime courtroom show where Judge Greg Mathis presides over a variety of cases and disputes. In Season 19, Episode 5, viewers are introduced to a plaintiff named Jane who is suing her former friend, defendant Sarah, for unpaid rent and damages to her home.

Jane tells Judge Mathis that she and Sarah were friends for over 10 years and had been living together for several months. However, Sarah stopped paying her portion of the rent and left the apartment without notice, leaving behind significant damages that Jane had to repair out of her own pocket. Jane is seeking $3,000 in damages.

Sarah, on the other hand, denies owing Jane any money and claims that they never had a formal rent agreement. She also alleges that Jane threatened her and repossessed her property without notice. Sarah is countersuing Jane for $1,500.

As the case unfolds, Judge Mathis listens to each side's testimony and examines evidence presented in the form of text messages and receipts. He also hears from witnesses who were present during the dispute.

Throughout the episode, Judge Mathis uses his trademark humor and no-nonsense approach to get to the bottom of the case and determine who is in the wrong. He challenges both Jane and Sarah on their actions leading up to and following the dispute.

While both Jane and Sarah display emotional outbursts during the hearing, Judge Mathis remains calm and firm, ensuring that both parties have a fair chance to present their case. He also offers practical advice and insight into how they could have avoided the conflict in the first place.

Ultimately, Judge Mathis makes a ruling based on the evidence presented and orders Sarah to pay Jane $2,000 in damages. He also dismisses Sarah's countersuit against Jane.

Throughout the episode, viewers are reminded that even close friendships can be tested when money and living situations are involved. Judge Mathis serves as a reminder that it's always best to have a clear agreement in place and to communicate effectively to avoid misunderstandings and conflicts.