Judge Mathis Season 23 Episode 21 Episode 21

Judge Mathis season 23 episode 21 centers around a case that involves a dispute over a rental car. The plaintiff in this case, Mr. Johnson, claims that the defendant, Ms. Williams, damaged his rental car and refuses to pay for the damages. Ms. Williams denies causing any damage to the vehicle and insists that she returned it in the same condition as she received it.

Judge Mathis opens the case by asking Mr. Johnson to explain the nature of the rental and how Ms. Williams allegedly caused the damages. Mr. Johnson explains that he rented the car to Ms. Williams for a weekend trip. When she returned the vehicle, he immediately noticed several scratches and dents on the car's body that were not present when he gave it to her. He accuses Ms. Williams of being negligent and careless with the rental, causing the damage while driving.

Ms. Williams responds by saying that the damages were already there when she rented the vehicle. She argues that she did not have an accident while driving and that Mr. Johnson is simply looking for a way to get more money out of her. She suggests that Mr. Johnson is simply trying to take advantage of her because she is a young woman.

Judge Mathis listens carefully to both sides of the argument and asks each of them to provide evidence to support their claims. Mr. Johnson shows pictures of the rental car before and after the rental and points out the damages. He also provides documentation from the rental company that shows the cost of the repairs and a statement from the mechanic that fixed the car.

Ms. Williams, on the other hand, does not have any evidence to support her claims. She simply insists that she did not cause the damages and asks Judge Mathis to believe her words. Judge Mathis reminds Ms. Williams that the burden of proof is on the plaintiff in this case and that she needs to provide evidence to support her argument.

After reviewing the evidence and listening to the arguments, Judge Mathis makes his ruling. He explains that the evidence presented by Mr. Johnson is compelling and that his story is more credible than Ms. Williams'. He notes that Ms. Williams did not provide any evidence to support her argument and simply relied on her words.

Judge Mathis orders Ms. Williams to pay for the damages to the rental car, as well as the court fees and other expenses associated with the case. He reminds Ms. Williams to be more careful and responsible when renting a car in the future and advises Mr. Johnson to use a reputable rental agency that offers insurance coverage for damages.

Overall, Judge Mathis season 23 episode 21 is an engaging and informative episode that provides insight into the legal system and how disputes are resolved in court. It shows how important it is to have evidence to support your claims and how negligence and carelessness can lead to legal problems. The episode also highlights the importance of being responsible and taking care of rental property, especially when it comes to cars and other vehicles.