Ep 5. The Gone Girls

In episode 5 of Still a Mystery season 1, entitled "The Gone Girls," viewers are introduced to the perplexing story of two teenage girls who vanished from their hometown in a small Missouri town over two decades earlier.

The girls, Stacy McCall and Suzie Streeter, were last seen in the early hours of June 7, 1992, after attending a high school graduation party. Their car was found abandoned outside of Streeter's home, but there was no sign of the girls or any indication of foul play.

The disappearance of the two popular and well-liked teenagers sent shockwaves through their community, and the case has remained unsolved for more than 25 years. In this episode, the hosts of Still a Mystery delve deep into the investigation, exploring potential suspects and examining new leads that have emerged over the years.

One of the key suspects in the case is a man named Robert Craig Cox, a convicted kidnapper and murderer who lived in the area at the time of the disappearances. Cox has been linked to the case through a series of unusual coincidences, and his statements to law enforcement have not always been consistent. However, despite extensive investigations and interrogations, no direct evidence has ever been found linking Cox to the disappearances of McCall and Streeter.

In addition to Cox, other potential suspects have arisen over the years, including a local man with a history of violence against women and a group of transient workers who were in the area around the time of the disappearances. However, none of these leads have ever panned out, leaving the case at a frustrating standstill.

As the hosts of Still a Mystery investigate the case, they interview friends and family members of the missing girls, as well as law enforcement officials who have worked on the case over the years. They also examine physical evidence, including DNA samples and witness testimony, in an effort to shed new light on the mysterious disappearance of these two young women.

Throughout the episode, viewers are reminded of the impact that the girls' disappearance has had on their families and the entire community. Despite widespread efforts to find them and solve the mystery, the case remains one of the most baffling and heartbreaking in Missouri's history.

Overall, this episode of Still a Mystery offers a sobering look at a case that has defied resolution for more than 25 years. Through interviews, archival footage, and expert analysis, viewers are given a detailed picture of the investigation and the ongoing efforts to find answers for the families of Stacy McCall and Suzie Streeter.