Still a Mystery

Watch Still a Mystery

  • 2019
  • 5 Seasons
  • 6.6  (129)

Still a Mystery is a true crime show that premiered on Investigation Discovery in 2018 and aired until 2022. The show explores some of the most fascinating and perplexing cases that have left investigators and families baffled, even after years or even decades of investigation. Hosted by Benita Alexander-Noel, Andrew McPherson, and Larry Mihlon, each episode delves deep into a different case, examining all the known facts and exploring the different theories and possible leads.

One of the standout features of Still a Mystery is the way it focuses on cases that have remained unresolved despite the efforts of law enforcement and other investigators. These cases range from missing persons to murders and other crimes, but all share the same common thread of being shrouded in mystery. Rather than simply rehashing the known facts, the show works to uncover new details and perspectives that could potentially help bring closure to these unsolved cases.

Another unique aspect of Still a Mystery is the way it gives voice to the families and loved ones of the victims. In many cases, the show interviews family members and friends who have been tirelessly searching for answers for years or even decades. These emotional interviews provide a humanizing element to the cases, and help to emphasize the very real impact that unsolved crimes can have on those left behind.

The hosts of Still a Mystery bring a wealth of expertise and knowledge to the show. Benita Alexander-Noel is a veteran investigative journalist who has worked on high-profile cases around the world. Andrew McPherson is a former homicide detective who has investigated some of the most notorious cases in recent history. And Larry Mihlon is a forensic profiler and veteran investigator who has appeared on numerous true crime shows over the years. Together, they provide a comprehensive and thoughtful analysis of each case, and always approach the investigations with an open mind and a commitment to uncovering the truth.

The show covers a wide range of cases, from the disappearance of Indiana University student Lauren Spierer to the unsolved murder of Tammy Zywicki, a college student who was found dead on the side of an Illinois highway in 1992. Other cases explored on the show include the mysterious death of Kenneka Jenkins, a teenager who was found dead in a hotel freezer; the bizarre murder of aspiring model Kelsey Smith-Briggs, who died at the hands of her stepfather; and the devastating mass shooting at the Route 91 Harvest music festival in Las Vegas.

Throughout the show, the hosts utilize a variety of investigative techniques and technologies to uncover new information about each case. They consult with experts in fields like forensics, psychology, and criminal justice, and often utilize cutting-edge methods like DNA analysis and facial reconstruction. They also pore over police reports and court documents, interview witnesses and family members, and even visit the sites of the crimes themselves to gain a deeper understanding of what happened.

Ultimately, Still a Mystery is a riveting and thought-provoking look at some of the most perplexing cases in recent history. Whether you're a true crime fan looking for a new show to binge-watch, or you're interested in the complexities of criminal investigations, this show is sure to keep you on the edge of your seat.

Still a Mystery is a series that is currently running and has 5 seasons (64 episodes). The series first aired on May 27, 2019.

Still a Mystery
Filter by Source

Do you have Hulu?
What are you waiting for?
Nice! Browse Hulu with Yidio.
Ad Info - This show may not be available on Hulu
The Stuff of Nightmares
10. The Stuff of Nightmares
May 18, 2023
A 14-year-old boy vanishes in Aruba while on a jet skiing outing with an older man he recently met. His mom immediately suspects that it isn't just a tragic accident. And someone abducts a young woman from her boyfriend's apartment building parking lot.
Unseen Enemies
9. Unseen Enemies
May 11, 2023
The murder of Barry and Honey Sherman in their mansion stuns Toronto.
Secrets in the DNA
8. Secrets in the DNA
May 4, 2023
A truck driver finds an unconscious woman on a Missouri motorway, and police determine the suspect attacked her elsewhere and placed her on the road; an unknown killer bludgeons a mum and her daughters at home while her son and nephew cling to life.
Suffer the Children
7. Suffer the Children
April 27, 2023
Oakley Carlson is turning five, and no one can find her, leaving her foster parents worried sick. And a young mother leaves a bar with a man she doesn't know -- and ends up dead.
What the Trees Know
6. What the Trees Know
April 20, 2023
A man from Georgia dies on a hunting trip with 17 stab wounds with his death declared as suicide. Another man goes missing, leaving only his burned-out car.
Suspicious Circumstances
5. Suspicious Circumstances
October 2, 2022
The families of two young mothers who died in suspicious circumstances search for answers; Racheyl Brinson's husband says she fell to her death while hunting, while Jessica Alva's boyfriend tells police that she hung herself.
The Party's Over
4. The Party's Over
September 25, 2022
A young woman acts erratically at a restaurant and police take her into custody; they release her in the middle of the night and she disappears; a soldier at Fort Hood dies after falling off a balcony.
Indiana Unsolved
3. Indiana Unsolved
September 18, 2022
A college student sends his sister a mysterious text about leaving the country. Later, his body turns up in a lake, weighed down by a backpack full of rocks. A young woman vanishes after trying to make a call from a payphone.
Danger at Close Range
2. Danger at Close Range
September 11, 2022
A bride-to-be vanishes weeks before her wedding. Suspicion swirls around her fiancé and ex-boyfriend, before a shocking revelation about a coworker makes him the main person of interest. Then, the mysterious death of a young trans woman.
Taken Before Graduation
1. Taken Before Graduation
September 4, 2022
Officers discover a high school senior's strangled body in flames weeks before graduation.
Where to Watch Still a Mystery
Still a Mystery is available for streaming on the Investigation Discovery website, both individual episodes and full seasons. You can also watch Still a Mystery on demand at Max, Amazon Prime, Philo, Amazon, Vudu, FuboTV, Sling, Google Play, Apple TV and Investigation Discovery.
  • Premiere Date
    May 27, 2019
  • IMDB Rating
    6.6  (129)