Judge Mathis Season 15 Episode 112 Episode 112
- March 31, 2014
Judge Mathis is a courtroom reality show that follows the cases presided over by retired Michigan Judge Greg Mathis. In each episode, Judge Mathis listens to both plaintiff and defendant arguments, examines evidence, and ultimately makes a ruling.
Season 15 of Judge Mathis includes Episode 112, which features a dispute between two neighbors, Alan and Mary. The case centers around the ownership of a fence that divides their respective properties.
In the opening moments of the episode, Judge Mathis introduces the case and welcomes Alan and Mary to the courtroom. Alan is dressed in casual attire, wearing a hoodie and jeans, while Mary appears in business attire, wearing a long skirt and blouse.
As the case begins, Alan explains his side of the dispute. He claims that he has paid for the fence and installed it on his property. However, Mary argues that the fence sits on the property line, which means they should share ownership.
Judge Mathis asks each party to provide evidence to support their claims. Alan pulls out receipts from the hardware store where he purchased the materials for the fence, as well as pictures of him installing it. Mary counters with a survey of the property, which she claims shows the fence sitting directly on the property line.
Judge Mathis pores over the evidence and comes to a conclusion. He rules that the fence should be considered shared property between Alan and Mary. He orders both parties to work together to maintain the fence and split the associated costs equally.
The episode then highlights another case, this one between a landlord, Sam, and his former tenant, Carla. Carla is suing Sam for keeping her security deposit after she vacated the apartment.
Sam claims that Carla caused significant damage to the apartment, including a broken window and damaged flooring. Carla, however, argues that the damages were minimal and that she left the apartment in good condition.
Once again, Judge Mathis examines the evidence provided by both parties. Sam produces pictures of the damages, while Carla presents a receipt for repairs she claims to have made before leaving the apartment.
After careful consideration, Judge Mathis sides with Carla. He rules that the damages were not severe enough to warrant keeping her entire security deposit and orders Sam to return a portion of the money.
Throughout the episode, Judge Mathis displays his signature style, mixing thoughtful consideration of evidence and a no-nonsense approach to justice. He remains respectful to both parties, offering guidance and wisdom, while also holding them accountable for their actions.
Judge Mathis' courtroom is a fascinating intersection of law, humanity, and entertainment, and Season 15 Episode 112 provides a compelling glimpse into this dynamic world.