Judge Mathis Season 15 Episode 19 Episode 19
- October 3, 2013
Judge Mathis is a popular reality TV show that follows the adventures of retired Michigan district court judge Greg Mathis. During each episode, Judge Mathis presides over small claims court cases and brings his unique brand of tough love to the proceedings. For episode 19 of season 15, Judge Mathis takes on a handful of cases that explore the intricacies of love, family, and friendship.
The first case features two friends who are at odds over money. The plaintiff lent the defendant $500 to pay for rent, but the defendant claims that it was a gift. The plaintiff insists that it was a loan and wants her money back, but the defendant has no intention of returning it. Judge Mathis listens to both sides carefully and finds that the defendant owes the plaintiff the full amount.
Next up is a case involving an unusual love triangle. The plaintiff claims that her boyfriend cheated on her with her best friend. She wants the defendant to stay away from her boyfriend and to pay for emotional damages. The defendant argues that she did not cheat with the plaintiff's boyfriend and would never do something like that. She insists that the plaintiff is simply jealous and trying to ruin their relationship. Judge Mathis sifts through the evidence and finds that the defendant did cheat with the plaintiff's boyfriend. He orders her to stay away from both of them and to pay for emotional damages.
The third case involves a family dispute over a car. The plaintiff claims that his sister sold him a car that was not functioning properly. He wants his money back and wants his sister to pay for repairs. The defendant argues that the plaintiff was aware of the car's problems before he purchased it and that she has no responsibility to pay for repairs. Judge Mathis investigates the car and finds that the defendant was aware of at least some of the issues before she sold it to her brother. He orders her to pay for half of the repairs.
In the fourth case, two friends are arguing over an engagement ring. The plaintiff claims that the defendant took her engagement ring and refuses to give it back. She wants the ring returned and wants the defendant to pay for damages. The defendant argues that the plaintiff gave her the ring as a gift and that it is rightfully hers. Judge Mathis examines the evidence and finds that the ring was, in fact, a gift. He dismisses the case.
The final case of the episode involves a dispute over property damage. The plaintiff claims that the defendant's dog destroyed her fence and that the defendant should pay for the repairs. The defendant argues that her dog never went near the plaintiff's fence and that she is not responsible for the damage. Judge Mathis hears from witnesses and ultimately finds that the defendant's dog did, in fact, damage the plaintiff's fence. He orders the defendant to pay for the repairs.
Overall, episode 19 of season 15 of Judge Mathis is a compelling look at small claims court cases that deal with the complexities of human relationships. From friends at odds over money to a love triangle gone wrong, Judge Mathis brings his trademark wisdom and insight to help resolve each case fairly and justly.