Ep 3. Broken Door Theory

The Good Guys season 1 episode 3, titled "Broken Door Theory," follows the antics of Detective Dan Stark and his partner, Detective Jack Bailey, as they investigate a robbery at a wealthy woman's home. The episode begins with Stark and Bailey responding to a call about a break-in at the home of a wealthy widow named Marjorie Dawes. Upon arrival, they discover that the robber has stolen a valuable painting that Dawes prized above all else.

Initially, Stark and Bailey believe that the robbery was an inside job and that one of Dawes' caregivers, who were both present during the theft, might be responsible. As they interview the caregivers, they start to suspect that they may have been wrong about who the perpetrator is. Instead, their focus turns towards a former housekeeper, who was fired by Dawes for stealing a diamond ring, and her boyfriend. Stark and Bailey believe that they are the ones who committed the robbery.

Throughout the investigation, Stark and Bailey have to contend with their differences in personality and methods. Bailey is by the book, and wants to do everything by the rules, whereas Stark is a rogue detective who likes to take shortcuts. However, their differences ultimately help them to arrive at the truth - using Stark's unorthodox "Broken Door Theory," they are able to confirm that the housekeeper and her boyfriend are the culprits.

Along the way, there are multiple twists and turns that keep the viewer engaged, including a subplot involving a romantic connection between Dawes and Stark. The viewer also gets a glimpse into the private lives of the detectives, including Bailey's struggle with his ex-wife's remarriage and Stark's complicated relationship with his ex-partner.

Overall, "Broken Door Theory" is an entertaining episode that showcases the chemistry between the two lead actors, Bradley Whitford and Colin Hanks. The show strikes a balance between humor and drama, with comedic moments that never undermine the seriousness of the crimes being investigated. The Good Guys may have only lasted for one season, but it left a lasting impression on viewers who appreciated its unique blend of old-school cop show tropes and modern sensibilities.