Judge Judy Season 1 Episode 113 Friendship goes to the dogs.
- February 19, 1997
In Judge Judy season 1 episode 113, titled "Friendship goes to the dogs," Judge Judith Sheindlin presides over a case involving two former friends who are now at odds over a dog. The case opens with plaintiff Chad, who is suing his former friend and roommate, defendant Eric, for the value of a pitbull puppy that they co-owned. Chad claims that Eric took the dog and refused to give it back, while Eric contends that he should have sole ownership of the animal since he has been the primary caregiver.
As the case unfolds, it becomes clear that the two friends had a falling out over the dog, which was a gift to them both from a mutual friend. Chad claims that Eric became possessive of the animal, insisting on keeping it in his bedroom and refusing to let Chad spend time with it. Eric, on the other hand, argues that he had to take care of the dog because Chad was never around and didn't contribute to its care.
Judge Judy listens to both sides of the story and examines evidence presented by both parties, including photos of the dog and receipts for its care. She questions Chad about why he didn't file a police report or take legal action earlier if he believed the dog was stolen, and questions Eric about his willingness to share the dog with Chad even if he felt Chad wasn't doing his fair share.
Throughout the case, tensions between Chad and Eric are high, and Judge Judy often has to intervene to prevent the two men from interrupting each other or talking over her. She challenges both parties to be honest about their intentions and their roles in caring for the dog.
In the end, Judge Judy rules that both Chad and Eric have an equal ownership stake in the pitbull puppy and orders them to divide all expenses related to its care. She also admonishes them to act like adults and find a way to share the dog without resorting to legal action or further conflict.
Overall, "Friendship goes to the dogs" is an engaging episode of Judge Judy that explores the complex relationships that can arise over the ownership of a pet. Judge Judy's no-nonsense approach and ability to cut through the emotions and get to the heart of the matter make for compelling viewing, as do the personalities of Chad and Eric themselves. Whether you're a fan of courtroom dramas or simply love dogs, this episode is sure to satisfy.