Judge Judy Season 1 Episode 123 Basketball fans; borrowed money.
- March 5, 1997
As a court television show, Judge Judy is a platform where petty issues escalate into full-blown legal problems. In season one, episode 123 titled "Basketball Fans; Borrowed Money," two cases were presented before Judge Judy. The first case involves two basketball fans who went to see a game together. The plaintiff claims that the defendant failed to pay for their tickets and parking expenses. The second case is about a borrowed money dispute between two friends.
In the first case, the plaintiff narrates how he and the defendant planned to see a basketball game. According to him, the defendant agreed to split the costs of the tickets and parking with him. However, when they got to the game, the defendant only paid for his own ticket and failed to contribute to the parking expenses. The plaintiff claims that he had to pay $80 for the ticket and $20 for parking. Even though he has a receipt to show for it, Judge Judy questions why he didn't make the defendant pay his fair share at the time and waited until after the event to sue him.
The defendant claims that he did pay the plaintiff for both his ticket and the parking fee. He shows Judge Judy a debit card receipt of $80 as proof of payment. Judge Judy points out that the receipt is not for the parking expenses, and furthermore, the defendant's card was not charged $20 for parking. The defendant admits that he doesn't have a receipt for the parking. Judge Judy orders the plaintiff to bring in a copy of his debit card statement and dismisses the case until he can.
In the second case, the plaintiff claims that his friend borrowed $500 from him and hasn't paid it back. He produced a handwritten agreement as evidence. According to him, his friend has repeatedly promised to repay the money but has not followed through on that agreement.
The plaintiff's friend, the defendant, argues that he's paid back the debt in full. He presents Judge Judy with receipts of payments made to the plaintiff via a money transfer app. Judge Judy points out that the payment history shows that the defendant started repaying the money only after the plaintiff had filed the lawsuit. She also has issues with the agreement, which she calls ambiguous and advises the plaintiff against lending money without documenting the repayment plan carefully.
Judge Judy advises the plaintiff to settle the case outside of court because the agreement is unclear. She tells the defendant that even though the agreement doesn't look appropriate, he still has to repay the full amount of the debt according to their original agreement.
Overall, Judge Judy Season 1 Episode 123 "Basketball Fans; Borrowed Money," exemplified how people go to court over minor issues and a lack of clear understanding of their agreements. It is essential to have all the details in writing before lending money or making any financial commitments with friends or family to avoid the losses and frustration that result from ambiguous agreements. Judge Judy's witty and no-nonsense disposition in assessing controversies ensures that justice is served, and these cases are no exception.