Judge Judy Season 1 Episode 34 Woman sues ex-husband; ruined wedding photos.

In season 1 episode 34 of Judge Judy, a woman is suing her ex-husband over ruined wedding photos. The plaintiff claims that the defendant, her ex-husband, ruined all of their wedding photos by accidentally knocking over a vase of flowers, causing water damage to the pictures. The plaintiff is seeking damages for the cost of the photography services and for the emotional distress caused by the loss of the photos.

The defendant denies any responsibility for the damaged photos, stating that he was not even in the room when the vase was knocked over. He claims that the plaintiff's cousin, who was also present at the wedding, was responsible for the accident. He argues that the plaintiff should be suing her cousin instead.

Judge Judy examines the evidence presented by the plaintiff, which includes before and after photos of the damage. She also questions both parties and witnesses to try to determine who is at fault for the damaged photos.

As the case unfolds, it becomes clear that there is a history of animosity between the plaintiff and the defendant. They had a contentious divorce and have since not been on good terms. The defendant accuses the plaintiff of bringing this case out of spite and vindictiveness.

Judge Judy reminds both parties that the case at hand is about the damaged wedding photos, and any personal issues should not come into play. She advises them to focus on the facts of the case and not to let their emotions cloud their judgment.

After hearing all the evidence, Judge Judy makes her ruling. She determines that the defendant is responsible for the damaged photos, as he was present at the wedding and had a duty to exercise reasonable care to avoid damaging the photos. However, Judge Judy does not award the full amount requested by the plaintiff, as she believes that the emotional distress caused by the loss of the photos was not adequately proven.

In the end, the plaintiff is awarded a partial amount for the cost of the photography services and for the damage to the photos, while the emotional damages are denied. Both parties leave the courtroom unsatisfied, but Judge Judy reminds them that they need to move forward and focus on their futures rather than dwell on the past.

Overall, the episode offers a glimpse into the legal process and how a judge evaluates evidence and testimony to make a fair judgment. It also highlights the importance of separating personal issues from legal matters and focusing on the facts of the case at hand.