Judge Judy Season 17 Episode 171 Best Friend Desertion?; Old Car, New Fight!

In season 17 episode 171 of Judge Judy, titled "Best Friend Desertion?; Old Car, New Fight!", two friends come to court to settle a dispute over a car. The plaintiff rented a car for the defendant to use, but the defendant allegedly did not return it on time and damaged it. The defendant claims that the plaintiff gave her permission to keep the car longer and that the damage was already there when she received it.

Judge Judy listens carefully to both sides and asks for evidence to support their claims. She is skeptical of the defendant's story and asks her pointed questions to try to get to the truth. The plaintiff also presents evidence in the form of text messages and photos to support her case.

As the case unfolds, it becomes clear that there may have been some miscommunication between the two friends about the terms of the car rental. Judge Judy weighs the evidence and makes a ruling based on her interpretation of the contract and the testimony of both parties.

In the second case of the episode, a woman is suing her former friend for abandoning her car in her yard after promising to fix it. The plaintiff claims that the defendant left the car there for months without making any repairs, causing damage to her property. The defendant argues that she was doing her best to fix the car and that the plaintiff did not communicate clearly with her about the situation.

Judge Judy again listens carefully to both sides and asks probing questions to get to the bottom of the issue. She is tough on the defendant, pushing her to explain why she did not move the car or communicate more clearly with the plaintiff. Ultimately, Judge Judy has to decide who is responsible for the damage caused by the car and whether the defendant acted in good faith or not.

Throughout both cases, Judge Judy is her usual no-nonsense self, cutting through the drama and getting to the heart of the matter. She is tough on both plaintiffs and defendants when necessary, but also shows compassion when appropriate. By the end of the episode, the audience is left satisfied that justice has been served.