Judge Judy Season 17 Episode 249 Mom and Son's Fiancee Fight!; User Boyfriend; Door Destruction
- June 7, 2013
As the 249th episode of the 17th season of Judge Judy begins, the tension in the courtroom is palpable as the litigants enter. The case centers around a fight between a mother, her son's fiancée, and her son's roommate and his girlfriend; the dispute involves a destroyed door and a female user of a boyfriend.
The plaintiff, a woman named Susan, tells Judge Judy that she and her son, Joe, have been living with the defendant, a young woman named Heather, for several months. According to Susan, things began to go downhill after Heather started dating a man named Mike. Allegedly, Mike has been staying over at the apartment frequently, which Susan feels is inappropriate since he is not on the lease. When Susan asked Mike to leave one night, he allegedly became angry and broke down the door.
As the judge begins to question Susan further, it becomes clear that the source of the tension is not just Mike's presence in the apartment. Susan is also upset with Heather, whom she claims has been lying to her about her job and about her relationship with Mike. Heather denies these allegations and insists that she has been transparent with Susan from the start.
The situation becomes even more complicated when Joe enters the courtroom. He is engaged to Heather, but his relationship with his mother has been strained for years. According to Joe, his mother has always been overprotective, and he feels like she is trying to control his life by interfering in his relationship with Heather. Joe tells Judge Judy that he does not believe Heather has been lying to them and that his mother is simply trying to make trouble.
At this point, things take an unexpected turn when the defendant's roommate, a young woman named Samantha, enters the courtroom. Samantha tells Judge Judy that she has also been having problems with Susan and that she believes Susan is trying to break up her relationship with her boyfriend, who she refers to as a "user." Samantha explains that Susan has called the police on her boyfriend in the past and has accused him of stealing from her.
The judge is clearly taken aback by this new information and begins to question Samantha about her own behavior in the apartment. Samantha admits that she and her boyfriend have not been paying rent and that they have been causing a disturbance with their loud music and arguments. She also admits that her boyfriend has been using drugs in the apartment.
Despite the chaos in the courtroom, Judge Judy is determined to get to the bottom of the dispute. She listens carefully to each person's testimony, asking probing questions and taking note of inconsistencies in their stories. In the end, she is able to piece together a clear picture of what happened and to make a fair and just ruling based on the evidence.
Without spoiling the end of the episode, it can be said that Judge Judy's decision not only resolves the disputed matter, but also has a positive impact on the relationships between the litigants. With her characteristic wit and wisdom, the judge is able to cut through the drama and get to the heart of the matter, leaving everyone involved feeling heard and understood.