Judge Judy Season 18 Episode 44 Shih Tzu Attack; Baseball Card Caper

Mrs. Walters, an elderly woman, is suing her neighbor Ms. Johnson for damages incurred by her pet shih tzu, who allegedly attacked Walters' own dog. The case begins with an intense cross-examination of both parties. Judge Judy does not hold back, asking both women pointed questions about the circumstances of the incident. The neighbor Ms. Johnson argues that Walters' dog provoked the attack by barking and acting aggressively towards her shih tzu. However, Mrs. Walters maintains that the shih tzu should have been kept on a leash and that Ms. Johnson is responsible for the damage caused by her dog.

During the proceedings, a baseball card collector named Mr. Smith enters the courtroom with a separate issue. He is suing one of his friends, Mr. Johnson, for allegedly stealing a rare baseball card from him. Smith claims that he had shown the card to Johnson during a card-collecting event and later realized that the card was missing from his collection. He accuses Johnson of stealing it, an accusation that Johnson strongly denies.

The case takes an unexpected twist when a witness to the shih tzu attack comes forward and reveals that the dog's leash had been broken and was not properly secured by Ms. Johnson. Judge Judy, empathizing with Mrs. Walters' frustration and concern for her pet, orders Johnson to pay for the full cost of the veterinary bills.

As the baseball card dispute continues, Judge Judy skillfully narrows in on the details of the alleged theft. She asks both parties to provide evidence of the card's value, and scrutinizes their stories. In the end, she rules in favor of Mr. Smith, ordering Johnson to return the stolen card and to pay damages for any loss in value the card has suffered.

Overall, Judge Judy season 18 episode 44 presents an engaging mix of cases that demonstrate the judge's unyielding commitment to fairness and justice. Whether dealing with issues of pet ownership or accusations of theft, Judge Judy offers a master class in courtroom drama, showcasing the importance of evidence, argumentation, and presentation in legal proceedings.