Ep 11. What If?

In the eleventh episode of Drop Dead Diva's first season, titled "What If?," viewers are in for another captivating installment of this beloved dramedy series. As the title suggests, this episode delves into the intriguing realm of alternate realities, exploring the endless possibilities and what-ifs that might sprout from our choices and actions.

The episode opens with Jane Bingum (Brooke Elliott), the show's lovable protagonist who is actually the reincarnation of the deceased supermodel Deb Dobkins, facing a momentous turning point. As Jane, a brilliant lawyer with a heart of gold, defends her client in court, she is presented with a stunning offer that could change everything. This offer forces her to ponder what her life would have been like if she had gone down a different path. Suddenly, Jane finds herself transported to a parallel universe, where Deb is still alive, and life has taken an entirely different trajectory.

In this alternate reality, Deb is embarking on her wedding day preparations with her fiancé Grayson (Jackson Hurst). The audience quickly learns that in this world, Deb's emergence as an intelligent and compassionate soul still occurs, but instead of finding herself within Jane's curvaceous figure, she stays within her original body. Not only does this twist add an engaging layer to the story, but it also allows the characters to navigate unfamiliar territory and confront fundamental questions about identity and self-perception.

As Jane attempts to conform to her new reality, she can't help but marvel at the differences between this world and her own. Her professional life has shifted as well, and she works under the guidance of a highly successful and cutthroat lawyer named Claire Harrison (Sharon Lawrence), who is notorious for her ruthless litigation tactics. Jane's innate kindness and sense of justice clash with Claire's aggressive approach, leading her to question the effectiveness of her own methods.

Amidst the chaos of this alternate reality, Jane also discovers that she is engaged to Grayson—a development that both excites and perplexes her. As she grapples with her conflicting emotions, it becomes clear that this marriage proposal is anything but straightforward. Jane wrestles with her feelings for Grayson, uncertain if her heart belongs to him as Jane or if it still pines for him as Deb. The love triangle between Jane, Grayson, and the newly resurrected Deb adds a delightful layer of tension and emotion to the storyline, keeping audiences on the edge of their seats.

Meanwhile, back in the real world, Jane's closest friend and colleague, Stacy Barrett (April Bowlby), is left reeling from her best friend's sudden disappearance. As Stacy desperately tries to understand what has happened to Jane, she stumbles upon clues that lead her to believe that Jane has been transported to an alternate reality. Determined to bring her friend back, Stacy embarks on a quest to uncover the truth.

The episode expertly weaves together the parallel storylines, alternating between Jane's experiences in the alternate reality and Stacy's relentless investigation in the real world. As the two friends navigate different paths, each faced with their own set of challenges and revelations, the episode invites viewers to ponder the concept of destiny, the power of choice, and the influence our actions have on our lives.

"What If?" truly showcases the talents of the show's ensemble cast as they effortlessly traverse between the familiar and the unfamiliar. Brooke Elliott shines as both Jane and Deb, flawlessly capturing the contrasting personalities and vulnerabilities of the two characters. Jackson Hurst brings depth and complexity to Grayson, while April Bowlby infuses Stacy with warmth, determination, and an unwavering loyalty.

In this riveting episode, "What If?" challenges our perceptions of ourselves and others, reminding us that life is a delicate tapestry woven from countless what-ifs and infinite possibilities. With its clever plot twists, heartfelt performances, and thought-provoking themes, the eleventh episode of Drop Dead Diva's first season is a must-watch for fans and newcomers alike.