Ep 46. Rabbi Fred Neulander

In season 1, episode 46 of Mugshots, viewers are taken inside the shocking case of Rabbi Fred Neulander. The episode starts by introducing Rabbi Neulander as a prominent figure in the Jewish community in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. The rabbi was admired by many for his charitable work and inspiring sermons.

However, in November 1994, Rabbi Neulander's world was turned upside down when his wife, Carol Neulander, was found bludgeoned to death in their home. As the investigation began, suspicion quickly fell on the rabbi. The police discovered that Neulander was having an affair with a congregant at his temple, Elaine Soncini.

In the episode, we see interviews with detectives who describe the investigation as one of the most complex cases they had ever worked on. Mugshots also features interviews with the prosecutors who built the case against Neulander. They describe the difficulty in convicting someone as well-respected as a rabbi in the community.

The trial, which took place in 2002, was highly publicized and garnered national attention. Mugshots takes us through each dramatic day of the trial, including the testimonies of the key witnesses, the presentation of evidence, and the emotional reactions of both the prosecution and defense.

Through this journey, viewers see how Neulander’s web of lies unravels - from an extramarital affair to solicitation of murder. The show features interviews with key figures involved with the case, who delve into the intense emotions the trial stoked.

Overall, Mugshots season 1, episode 46 tells the harrowing story of the downfall of a well-respected religious leader, who was ultimately brought to justice. Viewers get an inside look into the complex investigation and trial that ended in the conviction of Rabbi Fred Neulander.