Ep 5. What is Really Happening?

In Breaking Amish season 1 episode 5, titled "What is Really Happening?", the cast members are still adjusting to their new lives in New York City. With just a few weeks left until they have to make a decision about returning to their Amish and Mennonite communities or staying in the city, the group is starting to feel the pressure of the impending deadline.

In this episode, the cast members delve deeper into their personal struggles and issues. Sabrina receives a shocking phone call from her ex-boyfriend Harry, which leaves her questioning everything she thought she knew about their relationship. She turns to her friends for support and advice, but ultimately must make a tough decision about whether she should trust Harry or move on from their tumultuous past.

Meanwhile, Kate continues to struggle with her conflicting feelings about her Amish upbringing and her desire for a more modern lifestyle. She clashes with Jeremiah, who is determined to maintain his connection with his Amish roots, and their disagreement ultimately leads to a heated argument.

Rebecca also faces a personal crisis when she discovers that she might be pregnant. She turns to Jeremiah for emotional support, but their close relationship raises questions for the rest of the group about whether they are just friends or something more.

As tensions rise, the cast members attend a party in Brooklyn, where they let loose and enjoy themselves. But the fun comes to an abrupt end when they receive devastating news about their families back in Pennsylvania. The group must come together to support each other and decide what their next steps will be.

Overall, Breaking Amish season 1 episode 5 is an emotional and dramatic installment that highlights the cast members' individual struggles as well as their growing bonds with each other. As they continue to navigate their new lives outside of their communities, they must confront their pasts and decide what kind of future they want for themselves.