E! True Hollywood Story Season 3 Episode 46 Long Island Scandal: The Buttafuocos & Amy Fisher

In season 3 episode 46 of E! True Hollywood Story, viewers dive into the infamous Long Island Scandal involving the Buttafuocos and Amy Fisher. This scandal made headlines in 1992 when Fisher, a 17-year-old girl, shot and injured Mary Jo Buttafuoco, the wife of Fisher's lover, Joey Buttafuoco.

The episode takes a deep dive into the relationships between Fisher, Joey, and Mary Jo. Viewers learn about the affair between Joey and Fisher, which began when Fisher was just 16 and continued for over a year. The Buttafuoco's marriage was strained, to say the least, and Mary Jo suspected her husband of infidelity but had no idea that it was with a teenager.

The episode explores how Fisher became obsessed with Joey and how she became increasingly unstable. Fisher believed that Joey would leave his wife for her, but when it became clear that he had no intention of doing so, Fisher became enraged. She decided to take matters into her own hands and, in May of 1992, she drove to the Buttafuoco's home and shot Mary Jo in the head.

Viewers also learn about the aftermath of the shooting and the media frenzy that followed. Fisher was quickly arrested and charged with attempted murder, while Joey vehemently denied any involvement in the crime. Mary Jo survived the shooting but was left permanently impaired.

Throughout the episode, viewers hear from those involved in the case, including Fisher herself, who was released from prison in 1999 after serving 7 years. Joey Buttafuoco speaks about his role in the affair and the shooting and expresses remorse for his actions. Mary Jo speaks about the physical and emotional toll the shooting had on her and her family.

The episode also touches on the media's role in the case, with interviews from journalists and legal experts. Viewers see how the story became a national sensation, with talk shows and tabloids obsessed with every detail. The case also inspired multiple TV movies and books.

Overall, Long Island Scandal: The Buttafuocos & Amy Fisher is a gripping look at one of the most notorious true crime cases of the 1990s. It explores the complex relationships between the three individuals involved and the intense media scrutiny that followed the shooting.